Mullen Kyla
J Law Med. 2015 Sep;23(1):218-42.
The Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights includes right 6: the "Right to be Fully Informed". Analysis of the Health and Disability Commissioners' opinions between 2008 and 2013 that have discussed right 6 shows that the duties on providers have increased in a number of areas: the need to inform of risks, including provider-inherent risks; open disclosure of adverse events; ongoing need to inform consumers throughout the therapeutic relationship; information of all available options; and provision of sufficient time between disclosure of information and obtaining informed consent for provision of health services. Following a breach opinion, the Human Rights Review Tribunal and the Health Practitioners Competency Tribunal, on occasion, have the opportunity to consider the case but their role in law development is limited compared with that of the Commissioner. The limitations of law development in this manner are discussed.
《健康与残疾服务消费者权利准则》包括第6条权利:“充分了解信息的权利”。对2008年至2013年期间讨论第6条权利的健康与残疾专员意见进行分析后发现,提供者在多个方面的责任有所增加:告知风险的必要性,包括提供者自身存在的风险;公开披露不良事件;在整个治疗关系中持续向消费者提供信息的必要性;告知所有可用选项;以及在披露信息与获得提供健康服务的知情同意之间留出足够时间。在出现违规意见后,人权审查法庭和健康从业者能力审查法庭有时有机会审理该案件,但与专员相比,它们在法律发展方面的作用有限。本文讨论了以这种方式进行法律发展的局限性。