Weigel Angelika, Hofmeister Dirk, Pröbster Kristin, Brähler Elmar, Gumz Antje
Department of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf and Schön Klinik Hamburg Eilbek, Martinistrasse 52, 20246, Hamburg, Germany.
Department of Medical Psychology and Medical Sociology, University of Leipzig, Philipp-Rosenthal-Straße 55, 04103, Leipzig, Germany.
Eat Weight Disord. 2016 Sep;21(3):445-451. doi: 10.1007/s40519-015-0237-5. Epub 2015 Nov 16.
Medical students have been found to be vulnerable to mental health problems due to the high pressures of medical school. Countries developing into industrial nations tend to adopt Western beauty ideals which might increase eating disorder risk.
This cross-sectional study compared eating (Eating Disorder Inventory 2 EDI-2) and general psychopathology (General Health Questionnaire-28) in medical students from the newly formed German states with a historical sample of East German medical students examined at the time of the German reunification. Current medical students were also compared to population-based samples assessed before the German Reunification as well as recently to consider time trends in EDI scores.
The current sample comprised 316 medical students (232 female) from the newly formed German states (mean age = 21.7 years, SD = 2.6). Significantly higher levels of drive for thinness as well as body dissatisfaction and higher levels of general psychopathology were displayed in female medical students 20 years after the German reunification. In male medical students, no significant changes of eating pathology were observable. However, male medical students expressed significantly more anxiety and insomnia and a higher GHQ-28 total score than their counterparts examined in 1989.
Twenty years after the Reunification, an acculturation to Western beauty ideals seems to be more pronounced in female than in male medical students. Still, as a group, medical students from the newly formed German states did not appear to display a particular risk to develop eating disorders. However, due to the low response rate, results of this study should be interpreted cautiously.
由于医学院校的高压力,医学生被发现易患心理健康问题。发展成为工业国家的国家往往采用西方的审美标准,这可能会增加饮食失调的风险。
这项横断面研究比较了来自德国新成立州的医学生的饮食情况(饮食失调问卷2,EDI - 2)和一般精神病理学情况(一般健康问卷 - 28),并与德国统一时检查的东德医学生历史样本进行了比较。还将当前的医学生与德国统一前评估的基于人群的样本以及最近的样本进行了比较,以考虑EDI分数的时间趋势。
当前样本包括来自德国新成立州的316名医学生(232名女性)(平均年龄 = 21.7岁,标准差 = 2.6)。德国统一20年后,女医学生表现出明显更高的追求瘦身的驱动力、身体不满以及更高水平的一般精神病理学症状。在男医学生中,未观察到饮食病理学的显著变化。然而,男医学生表现出明显更多的焦虑和失眠,并且总GHQ - 28得分高于1989年检查的同龄人。
统一20年后,西方审美标准的文化适应在女医学生中似乎比男医学生中更为明显。不过,作为一个群体,来自德国新成立州的医学生似乎没有表现出患饮食失调症的特别风险。然而,由于低回复率,本研究结果应谨慎解释。