Corlan Alexandru Dan, Ross John
Research Department, University and Emergency Hospital of Bucharest, 5 Bucharest, Romania;
Chemistry Department, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2015 Nov 17;112(46):14150-5. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1510927112. Epub 2015 Nov 2.
Calculating the probability of each possible outcome for a patient at any time in the future is currently possible only in the simplest cases: short-term prediction in acute diseases of otherwise healthy persons. This problem is to some extent analogous to predicting the concentrations of species in a reactor when knowing initial concentrations and after examining reaction rates at the individual molecule level. The existing theoretical framework behind predicting contagion and the immediate outcome of acute diseases in previously healthy individuals is largely analogous to deterministic kinetics of chemical systems consisting of one or a few reactions. We show that current statistical models commonly used in chronic disease epidemiology correspond to simple stochastic treatment of single reaction systems. The general problem corresponds to stochastic kinetics of complex reaction systems. We attempt to formulate epidemiologic problems related to chronic diseases in chemical kinetics terms. We review methods that may be adapted for use in epidemiology. We show that some reactions cannot fit into the mass-action law paradigm and solutions to these systems would frequently exhibit an antiportfolio effect. We provide a complete example application of stochastic kinetics modeling for a deductive meta-analysis of two papers on atrial fibrillation incidence, prevalence, and mortality.
目前,只有在最简单的情况下,才有可能计算出患者在未来任何时候每种可能结果的概率:对原本健康的人在急性疾病中的短期预测。这个问题在某种程度上类似于在知道初始浓度并在单个分子水平上研究反应速率后预测反应器中物质的浓度。预测传染病以及原本健康个体中急性疾病的即时结果背后的现有理论框架,在很大程度上类似于由一个或几个反应组成的化学系统的确定性动力学。我们表明,目前在慢性病流行病学中常用的统计模型对应于单反应系统的简单随机处理。一般问题对应于复杂反应系统的随机动力学。我们试图用化学动力学术语来阐述与慢性病相关的流行病学问题。我们回顾了可能适用于流行病学的方法。我们表明,一些反应不符合质量作用定律范式,这些系统的解决方案经常会表现出反投资组合效应。我们提供了一个随机动力学建模的完整示例应用,用于对两篇关于心房颤动发病率、患病率和死亡率的论文进行演绎荟萃分析。