Silliman Brian R, Schrack Elizabeth, He Qiang, Cope Rebecca, Santoni Amanda, van der Heide Tjisse, Jacobi Ralph, Jacobi Mike, van de Koppel Johan
Division of Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University, Beaufort, NC 28516;
Aquatic Ecology and Environmental Biology Group, Institute for Water and Wetland Research, Radboud University, 6525 AJ Nijmegen, The Netherlands; Conservation Ecology Group, Groningen Institute for Evolutionary Life Sciences, University of Groningen, 9700 CC Groningen, The Netherlands;
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2015 Nov 17;112(46):14295-300. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1515297112. Epub 2015 Nov 2.
Restoration has been elevated as an important strategy to reverse the decline of coastal wetlands worldwide. Current practice in restoration science emphasizes minimizing competition between out-planted propagules to maximize planting success. This paradigm persists despite the fact that foundational theory in ecology demonstrates that positive species interactions are key to organism success under high physical stress, such as recolonization of bare substrate. As evidence of how entrenched this restoration paradigm is, our survey of 25 restoration organizations in 14 states in the United States revealed that >95% of these agencies assume minimizing negative interactions (i.e., competition) between outplants will maximize propagule growth. Restoration experiments in both Western and Eastern Atlantic salt marshes demonstrate, however, that a simple change in planting configuration (placing propagules next to, rather than at a distance from, each other) results in harnessing facilitation and increased yields by 107% on average. Thus, small adjustments in restoration design may catalyze untapped positive species interactions, resulting in significantly higher restoration success with no added cost. As positive interactions between organisms commonly occur in coastal ecosystems (especially in more physically stressful areas like uncolonized substrate) and conservation resources are limited, transformation of the coastal restoration paradigm to incorporate facilitation theory may enhance conservation efforts, shoreline defense, and provisioning of ecosystem services such as fisheries production.
恢复已被提升为一项重要战略,以扭转全球沿海湿地退化的局面。当前恢复科学的实践强调尽量减少移栽繁殖体之间的竞争,以最大限度地提高种植成功率。尽管生态学的基础理论表明,在诸如裸底再定殖等高物理压力条件下,正物种相互作用是生物体成功的关键,但这种范式仍然存在。作为这种恢复范式根深蒂固程度的证据,我们对美国14个州的25个恢复组织的调查显示,超过95%的这些机构认为尽量减少移栽植物之间的负面相互作用(即竞争)将最大限度地促进繁殖体生长。然而,在西大西洋和东大西洋盐沼的恢复实验表明,种植配置的一个简单改变(将繁殖体彼此相邻放置,而不是相隔一定距离)会利用促进作用,平均产量提高107%。因此,恢复设计中的小调整可能会激发未被利用的正物种相互作用,从而在不增加成本的情况下显著提高恢复成功率。由于生物体之间的正相互作用在沿海生态系统中普遍存在(特别是在像未殖民化基质这样物理压力更大的区域),而且保护资源有限,将沿海恢复范式转变为纳入促进作用理论可能会加强保护工作、海岸线防御以及渔业生产等生态系统服务的提供。