Mazess R B, Barden H, Vetter J, Ettinger M
Department of Medical Physics, University of Wisconsin.
Ann Biomed Eng. 1989;17(2):177-81. doi: 10.1007/BF02368026.
Several noninvasive measurement methods are used for evaluation of metabolic disease. Single-photon (125I) scans of the peripheral skeleton are useful in some diseases but are ineffective in osteoporosis (even on the distal radius or os calcis) because they cannot predict spinal or femoral density. Also, peripheral measurements show high percentages of false negatives, that is many patients with fractures have normal peripheral density. Dual-photon (153Gd) scans of the spine, femur, and total skeleton are precise and accurate (2% error) and provide direct measurements of bone strength at fracture sites. This gives the best discrimination of abnormality and the most sensitive monitoring. Quantitative computed computed tomography (QCT) allows measurement of the spine but not the critical proximal femur area. QCT has a large accuracy error because (a) the limited area measured (under 5 cm3) fails to represent the total vertebral body, (b) technical errors, and (c) variable fat and osteoid influence the results.
几种非侵入性测量方法用于评估代谢性疾病。外周骨骼的单光子(125I)扫描在某些疾病中有用,但在骨质疏松症中无效(即使是在桡骨远端或跟骨),因为它们无法预测脊柱或股骨密度。此外,外周测量显示出高比例的假阴性,即许多骨折患者外周密度正常。脊柱、股骨和全身骨骼的双光子(153Gd)扫描精确且准确(误差为2%),并能直接测量骨折部位的骨强度。这能最好地区分异常情况并进行最敏感的监测。定量计算机断层扫描(QCT)可测量脊柱,但不能测量关键的股骨近端区域。QCT有较大的准确度误差,原因如下:(a)测量的有限区域(小于5立方厘米)不能代表整个椎体;(b)技术误差;(c)可变的脂肪和类骨质会影响结果。