Acero Fernández Doroteo, Morillas Cunill Rosa, Ferri Iglesias María José, Torras Collell Xavier, Vergara Gómez Mercedes, Zaragoza Velasco Natividad, López Nuñez Carmen, Forné Bardera Montserrat, Delgado Gómez Mercedes, Barenys Lacha Mercè, Torres Salinas Miquel, Villar Fernández Margarita, Durández Lázaro Rosa, Mariño Mendez Zoe
Hospital Universitario de Girona Doctor Josep Trueta, Girona, Spain.
Hospital Germans Trias i Pujol, CIBERehd, Badalona, Spain.
Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2016 Jun-Jul;39(6):377-84. doi: 10.1016/j.gastrohep.2015.10.005. Epub 2015 Nov 21.
Pivotal phase studies of telaprevir (TLV) and boceprevir (BOV) showed 10-56% rates of early treatment interruption. However, there have been no reports on the sustained virological response (SVR) rates of these patients.
To assess the SVR rate in a large cohort of patients who discontinued triple therapy with TLV or BOV for reasons other than stopping rules and to identify variables predicting SVR.
A survey was sent to 15 hospitals in Catalonia asking them to report all TLV/BOV treatments finished by 31 May 2014. Demographic, clinical, laboratory, liver fibrosis and therapeutic data were recorded for treatments with early discontinuation. Logistic regression analysis, ROC curves and prognostic assessment of the variables identified were calculated.
Twelve hospitals responded to the survey, representing 467 treatments and 121 (21.2%) early discontinuations, 76 (62.8%) due to stopping rules and 45 (37.2%) for other reasons. Early discontinuation was more frequent with BOV [38.2% (50/131) versus 21.1% (71/336) p<0.005], mainly due to stopping rules [78% (39/50) versus 52.1% (37/71); p=0.004]. SVR was achieved in 21/121 patients (17.4%), 19/71 (26.8%) treated with TLV and 2/50 (4.0%) treated with BOV. In patients discontinuing treatment for reasons other than stopping rules, SVR was achieved in 19/37 (55.9%) treated with TLV and in 2/11 (18.2%) treated with BOV. The SVR rate in patients treated with TLV who discontinued due to a severe adverse event was 61.5% (16/26). A logistic regression analysis was performed only with triple therapy with TLV and early discontinuation. The predictive variables of SVR were undetectable HCV-RNA at treatment week 4 and treatment length longer than 11 weeks. Treatment duration longer than 11 weeks showed the best accuracy (0.794), with a positive predictive value of 0.928.
Early discontinuation of TLV-based triple therapy due to reasons other than stopping rules still have a significant SVR rate (55.9%). Undetectable HVC-RNA at week 4 of treatment and treatment duration longer than 11 weeks are predictive of SVR in this subset of patients.
替拉韦啶(TLV)和博赛匹韦(BOV)的关键阶段研究显示早期治疗中断率为10% - 56%。然而,尚无关于这些患者持续病毒学应答(SVR)率的报道。
评估一大群因非停药规则原因而停用含TLV或BOV三联疗法的患者的SVR率,并确定预测SVR的变量。
向加泰罗尼亚的15家医院发送调查问卷,要求他们报告截至2014年5月31日完成的所有TLV/BOV治疗情况。记录早期停药治疗的人口统计学、临床、实验室、肝纤维化和治疗数据。计算逻辑回归分析、ROC曲线以及所确定变量的预后评估。
12家医院回复了调查,代表467例治疗,其中121例(21.2%)早期停药,76例(62.8%)因停药规则停药,45例(37.2%)因其他原因停药。BOV组早期停药更常见[38.2%(50/131)对21.1%(71/336),p<0.005],主要是由于停药规则[78%(39/50)对52.1%(37/71);p = 0.004]。121例患者中有21例(17.4%)实现SVR,接受TLV治疗的71例中有19例(26.8%),接受BOV治疗的50例中有2例(4.0%)。因非停药规则原因停药的患者中,接受TLV治疗的19/37例(55.9%)和接受BOV治疗的2/11例(18.2%)实现SVR。因严重不良事件停药的接受TLV治疗患者的SVR率为61.5%(16/26)。仅对含TLV三联疗法及早期停药进行逻辑回归分析。SVR的预测变量为治疗第4周时HCV - RNA检测不到以及治疗时长超过11周。治疗时长超过11周显示出最佳准确性(0.79),阳性预测值为0.928。
因非停药规则原因早期停用基于TLV的三联疗法仍有显著的SVR率(55.9%)。治疗第4周时HVC - RNA检测不到以及治疗时长超过11周可预测该亚组患者的SVR。