Deschodt Mieke, Claes Veerle, Van Grootven Bastiaan, Van den Heede Koen, Flamaing Johan, Boland Benoit, Milisen Koen
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Academic Centre for Nursing and Midwifery, KU Leuven, Kapucijnenvoer 35/4, Leuven B-3000, Belgium; Department of Geriatric Medicine, University Hospitals Leuven, Herestraat 49, Leuven B-3000, Belgium.
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Academic Centre for Nursing and Midwifery, KU Leuven, Kapucijnenvoer 35/4, Leuven B-3000, Belgium.
Int J Nurs Stud. 2016 Mar;55:98-114. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2015.09.015. Epub 2015 Oct 9.
Interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams are implemented in the acute hospital setting in several high-income countries to provide comprehensive geriatric assessment for the increasing numbers of older patients with a geriatric profile hospitalized on non-geriatric units. Given the inconclusive evidence on this care model's effectiveness to improve patient outcomes, health care policy and practice oriented recommendations to redesign the structure and process of care provided by interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams are needed. A scoping review was conducted to explore the structure and processes of interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams in an international context. As nurses are considered key members of these teams, their roles and responsibilities were specifically explored.
The revised scoping methodology framework of Arksey and O'Malley was applied.
An electronic database search in Ovid MEDLINE, CINAHL and EMBASE and a hand search were performed for the identification of descriptive and experimental studies published in English, French or Dutch until April 2014.
Thematic reporting with descriptive statistics was performed and study findings were validated through interdisciplinary expert meetings.
Forty-six papers reporting on 25 distinct interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams in eight countries across three continents were included. Eight of the 12 teams (67%) reporting on their composition, stated that nurses and physicians were the main core members with head counts varying from 1 to 4 members per profession. In 80% of these teams nurses were required to have completed training in geriatrics. Advanced practice nurses were integrated in eleven out of fourteen interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams from the USA. Only 32% of teams used formal screening to identify patients most likely to benefit from their intervention, using heterogeneous screening methods, and scarcely providing information on the responsibilities of nurses. Nurses were involved in the medical, functional, psychological and social assessment of patients in 68% of teams, either in a leading role or in collaboration with other professions. Responsibilities of interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams' nurses regarding in-hospital follow-up or transitional care at hospital discharge were infrequently specified (16% of teams).
This scoping review identified that the structure and processes of care provided to geriatric patients by interdisciplinary geriatric consultation teams are highly heterogeneous. Despite nurses being key team members, only limited information on their specific roles and responsibilities was identified. More research in this area is required in order to inform health care policy and to formulate practice oriented recommendations to redesign the interdisciplinary geriatric consultation team care model aiming to improve its effectiveness.
在一些高收入国家的急症医院环境中,设立了跨学科老年病咨询团队,以便为越来越多在非老年病科室住院的、具有老年病特征的老年患者提供全面的老年病评估。鉴于关于这种护理模式改善患者结局有效性的证据尚无定论,因此需要面向医疗保健政策与实践的建议,以重新设计跨学科老年病咨询团队所提供护理的结构与流程。开展了一项范围综述,以探究国际背景下跨学科老年病咨询团队的结构与流程。由于护士被视为这些团队的关键成员,因此对其角色与职责进行了专门探究。
采用了Arksey和O'Malley修订后的范围综述方法框架。
在Ovid MEDLINE、CINAHL和EMBASE中进行电子数据库检索,并进行手工检索,以识别截至2014年4月以英文、法文或荷兰文发表的描述性和实验性研究。
进行了带有描述性统计的主题报告,并通过跨学科专家会议对研究结果进行了验证。
纳入了46篇论文,这些论文报告了来自三大洲八个国家的25个不同的跨学科老年病咨询团队。在报告其组成的12个团队中,有8个团队(67%)表示护士和医生是主要核心成员,每个专业的人数从1到4人不等。在这些团队中,80%要求护士完成老年病学培训。美国14个跨学科老年病咨询团队中有11个纳入了高级实践护士。只有32%的团队采用正式筛查来确定最有可能从其干预中受益的患者,采用的筛查方法各异,且几乎没有提供关于护士职责的信息。68%的团队中,护士参与了对患者的医疗、功能、心理和社会评估,要么担任主导角色,要么与其他专业人员合作。跨学科老年病咨询团队护士在住院期间随访或出院时过渡护理方面的职责很少有明确规定(16%的团队)。
这项范围综述发现,跨学科老年病咨询团队为老年患者提供的护理结构和流程高度异质。尽管护士是团队的关键成员,但关于其具体角色和职责的信息却很有限。需要在这一领域开展更多研究,以便为医疗保健政策提供参考,并制定以实践为导向的建议,重新设计跨学科老年病咨询团队护理模式,旨在提高其有效性。