Tao Wenjing, Holmberg Dag, Näslund Erik, Näslund Ingmar, Mattsson Fredrik, Lagergren Jesper, Ljung Rickard
Upper Gastrointestinal Surgery, Department of Molecular medicine and Surgery, Karolinska Institutet, Norra Stationsgatan 67, 171 76, Stockholm, Sweden.
Department of Clinical Sciences, Danderyd Hospital, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Obes Surg. 2016 Aug;26(8):1750-6. doi: 10.1007/s11695-015-1994-y.
Swedish health registries are common sources of data for studies on the effects of obesity surgery, and there is a need to assess the quality of data in these registries. The aim of this study was to validate the registration of obesity surgery in the National Patient Registry (NPR) and the Scandinavian Obesity Surgery Registry (SOReg).
We randomly selected 962 out of 8501 registrations of obesity surgery in 2011 from the NPR and SOReg. Registered surgical procedures in the NPR and SOReg were compared to the medical records, and concordance was analyzed by calculating positive predictive value (PPV) with 95 % confidence interval (CI).
We received 938 (98 %) medical records for manual review. The overall PPV for obesity surgery was high in the NPR (PPV 97.0; 95 % CI 95.6-98.4) and even higher in SOReg (PPV 99.7; 95 % CI 99.3-100). Accuracy was higher for gastric bypass surgery than for other types of obesity surgery. Registrations that were misclassified as obesity surgery (n = 44) included reoperations due to complications or reconstruction to normal anatomy after previous obesity surgery (n = 11) and endoscopic procedures (n = 10).
Obesity surgery registrations in the NPR and SOReg have high accuracy and are reliable sources of data to identify patients having undergone obesity surgery. When it is of importance to distinguish between specific surgical procedures, non-gastric bypass surgeries in the NPR should ideally be supplemented with data from other sources.
瑞典健康登记系统是肥胖症手术效果研究常用的数据来源,有必要评估这些登记系统中数据的质量。本研究的目的是验证国家患者登记系统(NPR)和斯堪的纳维亚肥胖症手术登记系统(SOReg)中肥胖症手术登记信息的准确性。
我们从NPR和SOReg中2011年的8501例肥胖症手术登记信息中随机抽取了962例。将NPR和SOReg中登记的手术操作与病历进行比较,并通过计算阳性预测值(PPV)及95%置信区间(CI)来分析一致性。
我们收到了938份(98%)病历用于人工审核。NPR中肥胖症手术的总体PPV较高(PPV 97.0;95% CI 95.6 - 98.4),SOReg中的更高(PPV 99.7;95% CI 99.3 - 100)。胃旁路手术的登记准确性高于其他类型的肥胖症手术。被错误分类为肥胖症手术的登记信息(n = 44)包括因并发症进行的再次手术或先前肥胖症手术后恢复正常解剖结构的重建手术(n = 11)以及内镜手术(n = 10)。
NPR和SOReg中的肥胖症手术登记信息具有较高的准确性,是识别接受过肥胖症手术患者的可靠数据来源。当区分特定手术操作很重要时,NPR中非胃旁路手术的登记信息理想情况下应补充其他来源的数据。