Norman Paul, Wrona-Clarke Aleksandra
Department of Psychology, University of Sheffield.
Psychol Addict Behav. 2016 Jun;30(4):434-41. doi: 10.1037/adb0000144. Epub 2015 Dec 21.
Studies testing the effects of self-affirmation on alcohol-related cognitions and behavior in university students have produced equivocal results. Because self-affirmation is a motivational technique (i.e., designed to reduce defensive processing) it may need to be supplemented with volitional techniques, such as forming if-then plans, to translate positive intentions into behavior. Participants (N = 348) were randomly assigned to conditions in a 2 (self-affirmation) × 2 (implementation intention) between-participants factorial design. Participants completed a self-affirmation task (i.e., values essay) or not, read a summary about the health risks of binge drinking (8/6 units for men/women), and then completed an implementation intention task (i.e., forming if-then plans) or not. Participants then completed measures of message derogation, perceived risk, and intention as well as alcohol consumption 1 week later. All main and interaction effects for self-affirmation were nonsignificant. In contrast, participants who formed implementation intentions (vs. not) reported drinking fewer units of alcohol and engaged in binge drinking less frequently at 1-week follow-up. Additional analyses revealed that affirming a social value attenuated the effect of self-affirmation on intention, but augmented the effect of implementation intentions on behavior. Overall, the findings provide additional evidence for the positive effects of implementation intentions but question the use of self-affirmation to reduce alcohol consumption in university students. (PsycINFO Database Record
研究测试自我肯定对大学生与酒精相关的认知和行为的影响,结果并不明确。由于自我肯定是一种激励技巧(即旨在减少防御性加工),它可能需要辅以意志技巧,比如制定“如果……那么……”计划,以便将积极意图转化为行为。参与者(N = 348)被随机分配到一个2(自我肯定)×2(执行意图)的组间析因设计的条件中。参与者完成或未完成一项自我肯定任务(即价值观短文),阅读一篇关于暴饮健康风险的总结(男性/女性为8/6个单位),然后完成或未完成一项执行意图任务(即制定“如果……那么……”计划)。参与者随后完成信息贬低、感知风险和意图的测量,以及1周后的酒精摄入量测量。自我肯定的所有主效应和交互效应均不显著。相比之下,制定了执行意图(与未制定相比)的参与者在1周随访时报告饮酒单位数更少,暴饮频率更低。进一步分析表明,肯定一种社会价值观会减弱自我肯定对意图的影响,但会增强执行意图对行为的影响。总体而言,研究结果为执行意图的积极效果提供了更多证据,但对使用自我肯定来减少大学生酒精消费提出了质疑。(PsycINFO数据库记录