Polizzi Karen M, Roblin Douglas W, Mims Adrienne D, Harris Dianne, Tolsma Dennis D
Perm J. 2004 Spring;8(2):28-33. doi: 10.7812/TPP/04.967.
To evaluate social and program factors associated with the one-year smoking cessation rate among participants of a smoking cessation program at a managed care organization (MCO).
As implemented at this MCO, the Quit Smart(™) program incorporated group sessions taught by health educators, discount vouchers for nicotine replacement patches, self-help manuals, and a relaxation audiotape. A survey of 97 patients who participated in the program during 1999 or 2000 or both was administered one year after these participants completed the program.
Of the 97 participants, 58 responded to the survey. Nineteen (33%) reported not smoking at one year after completing the program; and 11 (19%) reported that they were smoking-abstinent for 12 months after completing the program. Compared with patients who did not use the nicotine patch, respondents who used the nicotine patch were significantly more likely (OR = 4.42 [1.12, 17.35]) to report not smoking at 12 months after completing the program and to be smoking-abstinent for 12 months after completing the program (OR = 8.31 [1.15-60.22]). Respondents who were exposed to smoking in two or three settings (ie, at home, with friends, at work) were significantly less likely to report smoking cessation at 12 months (OR = 0.12 [0.02, 0.70]) and to have abstained from smoking for 12 months (OR = 0.04 [0.01, 0.42]) than were respondents who were not exposed to smoking in these settings.
The Quit Smart(™) program achieved 12-month smoking cessation and abstinence rates comparable with those achieved by other multifactorial programs to promote smoking cessation. Subsidized therapy using the nicotine patch was effective for promoting smoking cessation. However, program success was inhibited by exposure to smoking in domestic and social situations.
评估在一家管理式医疗组织(MCO)的戒烟项目参与者中,与一年戒烟率相关的社会因素和项目因素。
在这家MCO实施的“智能戒烟”(™)项目包括由健康教育工作者授课的小组课程、尼古丁替代贴片的折扣券、自助手册以及一盘放松录音带。在97名于1999年或2000年或这两年期间参加该项目的患者完成项目一年后,对他们进行了一项调查。
97名参与者中,58人回复了调查。19人(33%)报告在完成项目一年后不再吸烟;11人(19%)报告在完成项目后已戒烟12个月。与未使用尼古丁贴片的患者相比,使用尼古丁贴片的受访者在完成项目12个月后报告不再吸烟以及在完成项目后已戒烟12个月的可能性显著更高(比值比[OR]=4.42[1.12,17.35])。在两种或三种场景(即在家中、与朋友在一起、在工作场所)接触吸烟的受访者在12个月时报告戒烟的可能性(OR=0.12[0.02,0.70])以及已戒烟12个月的可能性(OR=0.04[0.01,0.42])显著低于在这些场景中未接触吸烟的受访者。
“智能戒烟”(™)项目实现的12个月戒烟率和戒断率与其他促进戒烟的多因素项目相当。使用尼古丁贴片的补贴疗法对促进戒烟有效。然而,家庭和社交场合中的吸烟接触抑制了项目的成功。