Jakub James W, Terando Alicia M, Sarnaik Amod, Ariyan Charlotte E, Faries Mark B, Zani Sabino, Neuman Heather B, Wasif Nabil, Farma Jeffrey M, Averbook Bruce J, Bilimoria Karl Y, Allred Jacob B Jake, Suman Vera J, Grotz Travis E, Zendejas Benjamin, Wayne Jeffrey D, Tyler Douglas S
Department of Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Department of Surgery, Ohio State University Medical Center, Columbus, OH.
J Am Coll Surg. 2016 Mar;222(3):253-60. doi: 10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2015.11.010. Epub 2015 Nov 25.
Minimally invasive inguinal lymphadenectomy (MILND) is a novel procedure with the potential to decrease surgical morbidity compared with the traditional open approach. The current study examined the feasibility of a combined didactic and hands-on training program to prepare high-volume melanoma surgeons to perform this procedure safely and proficiently.
A select group of melanoma surgeons with no MILND experience were recruited. After completing a structured training program, surgeons enrolled patients with melanoma who required inguinal lymphadenectomy and performed the procedure in the minimally invasive fashion. A proficiency score composed of lymph node yield, operative time, and blood loss (or adverse events) was assigned for each case. After performing six cases, surgeons meeting a threshold score were considered proficient in the procedure.
Twelve surgeons from 10 institutions enrolled 88 patients. The majority of surgeons were deemed proficient within 6 cases (83%). No differences in operative time or lymph node yield were noted during the course of the study. The rate of conversion was higher during an individual surgeon's early experience (9 of 49 [18%]), and only 1 procedure was converted in the 39 cases performed after a surgeon had performed 5 cases (late conversion rate, 3%; p = 0.038); however, this did not remain significant after controlling for surgeon.
After a structured training program, experienced melanoma surgeons adopted a novel surgical technique with acceptable operative times, conversions, and lymph node yield. Eighty-four percent of the surgeons who completed at least 6 MILND procedures were considered proficient based on our predetermined definition.
与传统开放手术相比,微创腹股沟淋巴结清扫术(MILND)是一种有潜力降低手术并发症发生率的新手术方法。本研究探讨了结合理论教学与实践操作的培训方案,以使大量开展黑色素瘤手术的外科医生安全、熟练地实施该手术的可行性。
招募了一组无MILND经验的黑色素瘤外科医生。在完成结构化培训方案后,外科医生纳入需要腹股沟淋巴结清扫术的黑色素瘤患者,并以微创方式实施该手术。为每个病例分配一个由淋巴结获取量、手术时间和失血量(或不良事件)组成的熟练度评分。在完成6例手术后,达到阈值评分的外科医生被认为熟练掌握该手术。
来自10个机构的12名外科医生纳入了88例患者。大多数外科医生在6例手术内被认为熟练(83%)。在研究过程中,未观察到手术时间或淋巴结获取量的差异。在个别外科医生的早期经验中,中转率较高(49例中的9例[18%]),而在一名外科医生完成5例手术后进行的39例手术中,只有1例中转(晚期中转率,3%;p = 0.038);然而,在对医生进行校正后,这一差异不再显著。
经过结构化培训方案后,经验丰富的黑色素瘤外科医生采用了一种新的手术技术,其手术时间、中转率和淋巴结获取量均可接受。根据我们预先确定的定义,完成至少6例MILND手术的外科医生中有84%被认为熟练掌握该手术。