Dickson Hugh, Kavanagh David J, MacLeod Colin
Centre for Children's Health Research, Institute of Health & Biomedical Innovation and School of Psychology & Counselling, Queensland University of Technology, 62 Raymond Terrace, South Brisbane, Qld 4101, Australia.
School of Psychology, The University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia.
Appetite. 2016 Apr 1;99:46-51. doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2015.12.026. Epub 2015 Dec 25.
Previous research has shown that action tendencies to approach alcohol may be modified using computerized Approach-Avoidance Task (AAT), and that this impacted on subsequent consumption. A recent paper in this journal (Becker, Jostman, Wiers, & Holland, 2015) failed to show significant training effects for food in three studies: Nor did it find effects on subsequent consumption. However, avoidance training to high calorie foods was tested against a control rather than Approach training. The present study used a more comparable paradigm to the alcohol studies. It randomly assigned 90 participants to 'approach' or 'avoid' chocolate images on the AAT, and then asked them to taste and rate chocolates. A significant interaction of condition and time showed that training to avoid chocolate resulted in faster avoidance responses to chocolate images, compared with training to approach it. Consistent with Becker et al.'s Study 3, no effect was found on amounts of chocolate consumed, although a newly published study in this journal (Schumacher, Kemps, & Tiggemann, 2016) did do so. The collective evidence does not as yet provide solid basis for the application of AAT training to reduction of problematic food consumption, although clinical trials have yet to be conducted.
先前的研究表明,利用计算机化的趋近-回避任务(AAT)可以改变接近酒精的行为倾向,并且这会影响后续的饮酒量。该期刊最近发表的一篇论文(贝克尔、约斯特曼、维尔斯和霍兰德,2015年)在三项研究中未发现针对食物的显著训练效果:也未发现对后续食物摄入量的影响。然而,针对高热量食物的回避训练是与对照组进行对比测试的,而非趋近训练。本研究采用了与酒精研究更具可比性的范式。它将90名参与者随机分配到AAT中“趋近”或“回避”巧克力图片的任务组,然后让他们品尝并评价巧克力。条件和时间的显著交互作用表明,与趋近训练相比,回避巧克力的训练导致对巧克力图片的回避反应更快。与贝克尔等人的研究3一致,尽管该期刊最近发表的一项研究(舒马赫、肯普斯和蒂格曼,2016年)发现了训练效果,但本研究未发现对巧克力摄入量有影响。尽管尚未进行临床试验,但现有证据尚未为应用AAT训练来减少问题性食物消费提供坚实基础。