Heller Katharina, Bullerjahn Claudia, von Georgi Richard
Institute of Musicology and Music Education, Justus-Liebig-University Giessen Giessen, Germany.
Institute of Musicology and Music Education, Justus-Liebig-University GiessenGiessen, Germany; International Psychoanalytic University BerlinBerlin, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2015 Dec 21;6:1901. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01901. eCollection 2015.
Most of the existing studies on musical practice are concerned with instrumentalists only. Since singers are seldom considered in research, the present study is based on an online-sample of amateur vocal students (N = 120; 92 female, 28 male). The study investigated the correlations between personality traits, flow-experience and several aspects of practice characteristics. Personality was represented by the three personality dimensions extraversion, neuroticism and psychoticism, assessed by Eysenck's Personality Profiler as well as the trait form of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule. 'Flow-experience,' 'self-congruence' and 'fear of losing control over concentration,' assessed by the Practice Flow Inventory, served as variables for flow-experience. The practice motivation was measured by the Practice Motivation Questionnaire in four categories ('self,' 'group,' 'audience,' 'teacher'). In addition, the Practice Behavior Questionnaire was used to provide an insight into the practice situation and behavior of singing students. The results show significant correlations: participants with high extraversion-scores experience significantly more flow than less extraverted persons, whereas lesser flow-experience seems to be related to high neuroticism-scores. Nevertheless, there is no influence in flow-experience concerning singing style ('classical' or 'popular'). The longer the practicing time, the more likely students are to achieve flow-experience. However, older singers tend to have less flow-experience. Consequently, singers seem to differ in their personality and practice behavior compared to other musicians. Most of the findings show that having control over one's instrument is decisive for achieving a performance of high quality, especially for singers. On the other hand, certainty in handling an instrument is essential to arouse a flow-feeling. However, flow-experience seems to be common mainly with amateur singers. In conclusion, this offers a starting point for new research on the psychology of vocalists in greater depth.
现有的大多数关于音乐练习的研究仅关注器乐演奏者。由于在研究中很少考虑歌手,因此本研究基于一个业余声乐学生的在线样本(N = 120;92名女性,28名男性)。该研究调查了人格特质、心流体验与练习特征的几个方面之间的相关性。人格由外向性、神经质和精神质这三个人格维度来代表,通过艾森克人格问卷以及正负性情绪量表的特质形式进行评估。通过练习心流量表评估的“心流体验”“自我一致性”和“害怕失去对注意力的控制”作为心流体验的变量。练习动机通过练习动机问卷从四个类别(“自我”“团体”“观众”“教师”)进行测量。此外,练习行为问卷被用于深入了解歌唱学生的练习情况和行为。结果显示出显著的相关性:外向性得分高的参与者比外向性较低的人体验到的心流明显更多,而较少的心流体验似乎与高神经质得分有关。然而,歌唱风格(“古典”或“流行”)对心流体验没有影响。练习时间越长,学生越有可能获得心流体验。然而,年长的歌手往往心流体验较少。因此,与其他音乐家相比,歌手在人格和练习行为上似乎存在差异。大多数研究结果表明,对自己的乐器有掌控力对于实现高质量的表演至关重要,尤其是对于歌手而言。另一方面,熟练操作乐器对于唤起心流感受至关重要。然而,心流体验似乎主要在业余歌手中较为常见。总之,这为更深入地研究声乐家心理学提供了一个新的起点。