Beniwal Lindsay A, Kleven Karen L, Moody Leslie T, Molin Brianna M, Kantola Stephanie J, Carlson Michelle L, Schuning Virginia S, Jain Sneha, van Buskirk Camille M, Harris Malinda N, Carey William A, Ellsworth Marc A
Department of Nursing (Mss Beniwal, Kleven, Moody, and Schuning), Division of Neonatal Medicine (Mss Molin, Kantola, and Carlson and Drs Harris, Carey, and Ellsworth), Quality Academy (Ms Jain), and Division of Transfusion Medicine (Dr Buskirk), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
Adv Neonatal Care. 2016 Feb;16(1):E3-9. doi: 10.1097/ANC.0000000000000249.
Extremely low birth-weight (ELBW) infants frequently receive packed red blood cell (PRBC) transfusions. Recent studies have shown that more restrictive PRBC transfusion guidelines limit donor exposure and reduce transfusion-related costs without any increase in adverse clinical outcomes.
We developed and implemented an evidence-based PRBC transfusion guideline for ELBW infants treated in our unit and then measured provider adherence to this guideline.
METHODS/SEARCH STRATEGY: We performed a retrospective review of all PRBC transfusions given to ELBW infants in 2012 (preguideline) and the first half of 2014 (postguideline). We identified the indication for each transfusion by reviewing physiological/laboratory data and the daily clinical note. We then determine whether each transfusion met criteria according to our new evidence-based guideline.
FINDINGS/RESULTS: When extrapolating the newly developed protocol to 2012 data, less than 15% of transfusions among ELBW infants would have met the current evidence-based standard. Conversely, during the first 6 months of 2014, 61% of transfusions were administered in adherence to the guideline (P < 001). Using current cost estimates, this represents a projected cost savings of $31,000 in that 6-month period.
A multidisciplinary approach to improving PRBC transfusion practices results in potentially safer, more cost-effective care for ELBW infants.
Given the frequency, potential harms, and costs associated with PRBC transfusions in ELBW infants, it seems both feasible and important to pursue prospective clinical trials comparing permissive and restrictive approaches to transfusion in this vulnerable population.
极低出生体重(ELBW)婴儿经常接受浓缩红细胞(PRBC)输血。最近的研究表明,更严格的PRBC输血指南可限制供体暴露并降低输血相关成本,且不会增加不良临床结局。
我们制定并实施了一项针对在本单位接受治疗的ELBW婴儿的循证PRBC输血指南,然后评估医护人员对该指南的遵循情况。
方法/检索策略:我们对2012年(指南制定前)和2014年上半年(指南制定后)给予ELBW婴儿的所有PRBC输血进行了回顾性研究。通过审查生理/实验室数据和每日临床记录来确定每次输血的指征。然后根据我们新的循证指南确定每次输血是否符合标准。
将新制定的方案推算至2012年的数据时,ELBW婴儿中只有不到15%的输血符合当前的循证标准。相反,在2014年的前6个月,61%的输血是按照指南进行的(P<0.001)。根据目前的成本估算,这意味着在那6个月期间预计可节省31,000美元。
采用多学科方法改善PRBC输血实践可为ELBW婴儿提供潜在更安全、更具成本效益的护理。
鉴于ELBW婴儿PRBC输血的频率、潜在危害和成本,开展前瞻性临床试验比较在这一脆弱人群中采用宽松和严格输血方法似乎既可行又重要。