Müller Andre Matthias, Khoo Selina, Morris Tony
Sports Centre, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
J Med Internet Res. 2016 Jan 7;18(1):e5. doi: 10.2196/jmir.5235.
Mobile technology to promote exercise is effective; however, most evidence is from studies of younger groups in high-income countries. Investigating if short message service (SMS) texting can affect exercise participation in older adults from an upper-middle-income country is important considering the proliferation of mobile phones in developing regions and the increased interest of older adults in using mobile phones.
The main objective was to examine the short- and long-term effects of SMS text messaging on exercise frequency in older adults. Secondary objectives were to investigate how SMS text messages impact study participants' exercise frequency and the effects of the intervention on secondary outcomes.
The Malaysian Physical Activity for Health Study (myPAtHS) was a 24-week, 2-arm, parallel randomized controlled trial conducted in urban Malaysia. Participants were recruited via health talks in resident associations and religious facilities. Older Malaysians (aged 55-70 years) who used mobile phones and did not exercise regularly were eligible to participate in the study. Participants randomly allocated to the SMS texting arm received an exercise booklet and 5 weekly SMS text messages over 12 weeks. The content of the SMS text messages was derived from effective behavior change techniques. The non-SMS texting arm participants received only the exercise booklet. Home visits were conducted to collect outcome data: (1) exercise frequency at 12 and 24 weeks, (2) secondary outcome data (exercise self-efficacy, physical activity-related energy expenditure, sitting time, body mass index, grip and leg strength) at baseline and at 12 and 24 weeks. Intention-to-treat procedures were applied for data analysis. Semistructured interviews focusing primarily on the SMS text messages and their impact on exercise frequency were conducted at weeks 12 and 24.
In total, 43 participants were randomized into the SMS texting arm (n=22) and the non-SMS texting arm (n=21). Study-unrelated injuries forced 4 participants to discontinue after a few weeks (they were not included in any analyses). Overall retention was 86% (37/43). After 12 weeks, SMS texting arm participants exercised significantly more than non-SMS texting arm participants (mean difference 1.21 times, bias-corrected and accelerated bootstrap [BCa] 95% CI 0.18-2.24). Interview analysis revealed that the SMS text messages positively influenced SMS texting arm participants who experienced exercise barriers. They described the SMS text messages as being encouraging, a push, and a reminder. After 24 weeks, there was no significant difference between the research arms (mean difference 0.74, BCa 95% CI -0.30 to 1.76). There were no significant effects for secondary outcomes.
This study provides evidence that SMS text messaging is effective in promoting exercise in older adults from an upper-middle-income country. Although the effects were not maintained when SMS text messaging ceased, the results are promising and warrant more research on behavioral mobile health interventions in other regions.
Clinicaltrials.gov NCT02123342; http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02123342 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/6eGSsu2EI).
利用移动技术促进锻炼是有效的;然而,大多数证据来自高收入国家针对较年轻群体的研究。鉴于发展中地区手机的普及以及老年人对使用手机兴趣的增加,研究短信服务(SMS)是否能影响来自中高收入国家的老年人的锻炼参与情况具有重要意义。
主要目的是研究短信服务对老年人锻炼频率的短期和长期影响。次要目的是调查短信如何影响研究参与者的锻炼频率以及干预措施对次要结果的影响。
马来西亚健康身体活动研究(myPAtHS)是在马来西亚城市进行的一项为期24周、双臂、平行随机对照试验。通过居民协会和宗教场所的健康讲座招募参与者。年龄在55 - 70岁、使用手机且不经常锻炼的马来西亚老年人有资格参与该研究。随机分配到短信组的参与者会收到一本锻炼手册,并在12周内每周收到5条短信。短信内容源自有效的行为改变技巧。非短信组参与者仅收到锻炼手册。通过家访收集结果数据:(1)12周和24周时的锻炼频率,(2)基线以及12周和24周时的次要结果数据(锻炼自我效能、与身体活动相关的能量消耗、久坐时间、体重指数、握力和腿部力量)。采用意向性分析方法进行数据分析。在第12周和第24周进行了主要围绕短信及其对锻炼频率影响的半结构化访谈。
总共43名参与者被随机分为短信组(n = 22)和非短信组(n = 21)。与研究无关的损伤迫使4名参与者在几周后退出(他们未纳入任何分析)。总体保留率为86%(37/43)。12周后,短信组参与者的锻炼次数显著多于非短信组参与者(平均差异1.21倍,偏差校正和加速自抽样[BCa]95%置信区间0.18 - 2.24)。访谈分析表明,短信对遇到锻炼障碍的短信组参与者产生了积极影响。他们将短信描述为鼓舞人心、一种推动和一种提醒。24周后,两组之间没有显著差异(平均差异0.74,BCa 95%置信区间 - 0.30至1.76)。次要结果没有显著影响。
本研究提供了证据表明短信服务在促进中高收入国家老年人锻炼方面是有效的。尽管短信服务停止后效果未持续,但结果很有前景,值得在其他地区对行为移动健康干预措施开展更多研究。
Clinicaltrials.gov NCT02123342;http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02123342(由WebCite存档于http://www.webcitation.org/6eGSsu2EI)