Li Zhoubo, Yu Lifeng, Leng Shuai, Williamson Eric E, Kotsenas Amy L, DeLone David R, Manduca Armando, McCollough Cynthia H
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905 and Biomedical Engineering and Physiology Graduate Program, Mayo Graduate School, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Med Phys. 2016 Jan;43(1):347. doi: 10.1118/1.4938576.
To develop a noise reduction method for time resolved CT data, especially those with significant patient motion.
PArtial TEmporal Nonlocal (PATEN) means is a technique that uses the redundant information in time-resolved CT data to achieve noise reduction. In this method, partial temporal profiles are used to determine the similarity (or weight) between pixels, and the similarity search makes use of both spatial and temporal information, providing robustness to patient motion. The performance of the PATEN filter was qualitatively and quantitatively evaluated with nine cardiac CT patient data sets and five CT brain perfusion patient data sets. In cardiac CT, PATEN was applied to reduce noise primarily in the reduced-dose phases created with electrocardiographic (ECG) pulsing. CT number accuracy and noise reduction were evaluated in both full-dose phases and reduced-dose phases between filtered backprojection images and PATEN filtered images. In CT brain perfusion, simulated quarter dose data were obtained by adding noise to the raw data of a routine dose scan. PATEN was applied to the simulated low-dose images. Image noise, time-intensity profile accuracy, and perfusion parameter maps were compared among low-dose, low-dose+PATEN filter, and full-dose images. The noise reduction performance of PATEN was compared to a previously proposed noise reduction method, time-intensity profile similarity (TIPS) bilateral filtering.
In 4D cardiac CT, after PATEN filtering, the image noise in the reduced-dose phases was greatly reduced, making anatomical structures easier to identify. The mean decreases in noise values between the original and PATEN images were 11.0% and 53.8% for the full and reduced-dose phases of the cardiac cycle, respectively. TIPS could not achieve effective noise reduction. In CT brain perfusion, PATEN achieved a 55.8%-66.3% decrease in image noise in the low-dose images. The contrast to noise ratio in the axial images was increased and was comparable to the full-dose images. Differentiation of anatomical structure in the PATEN images and corresponding quantitative perfusion parameter maps were preferred by two neuroradiologists compared to the simulated low-dose and TIPS results. The mean perfusion parameters calculated from the PATEN images agreed with those determined from full-dose data to within 12% and 20% for normal and diseased regions.
In ECG-gated cardiac CT, where the dose had already been reduced by a factor of 5 in the reduced-dose phases, PATEN achieved a 53.8% noise reduction, which decreased the noise level in the reduced-dose phases close to that of the full-dose phases. In CT brain perfusion, a fourfold dose reduction was demonstrated to be achievable by PATEN filtering, which improved quantitative perfusion analysis. PATEN can be used to effectively reduce image noise to improve image quality, even when significant motion occurred between temporal samples.
开发一种用于时间分辨CT数据的降噪方法,尤其是针对存在显著患者运动的情况。
部分时间非局部(PATEN)均值是一种利用时间分辨CT数据中的冗余信息来实现降噪的技术。在该方法中,部分时间轮廓用于确定像素之间的相似度(或权重),相似度搜索同时利用空间和时间信息,从而对患者运动具有鲁棒性。使用九个心脏CT患者数据集和五个CT脑灌注患者数据集对PATEN滤波器的性能进行了定性和定量评估。在心脏CT中,PATEN主要应用于通过心电图(ECG)脉冲创建的低剂量期以降低噪声。在滤波反投影图像和PATEN滤波图像之间的全剂量期和低剂量期评估CT值准确性和降噪情况。在CT脑灌注中,通过向常规剂量扫描的原始数据添加噪声获得模拟四分之一剂量数据。将PATEN应用于模拟低剂量图像。比较低剂量、低剂量+PATEN滤波器和全剂量图像之间的图像噪声、时间-强度曲线准确性和灌注参数图。将PATEN的降噪性能与先前提出的降噪方法时间-强度曲线相似度(TIPS)双边滤波进行比较。
在4D心脏CT中,经过PATEN滤波后,低剂量期的图像噪声大幅降低,使解剖结构更易于识别。心动周期的全剂量期和低剂量期原始图像与PATEN图像之间的噪声值平均降低分别为11.0%和53.8%。TIPS无法实现有效降噪。在CT脑灌注中,PATEN使低剂量图像中的图像噪声降低了55.8%-66.3%。轴向图像中的对比噪声比增加,与全剂量图像相当。与模拟低剂量和TIPS结果相比,两名神经放射科医生更倾向于PATEN图像及相应定量灌注参数图中的解剖结构区分。从PATEN图像计算出的平均灌注参数与从全剂量数据确定的参数在正常和病变区域内的误差分别在12%和20%以内。
在ECG门控心脏CT中,低剂量期剂量已降低5倍,PATEN实现了53.8%的降噪,将低剂量期的噪声水平降低至接近全剂量期。在CT脑灌注中,通过PATEN滤波证明可以实现四倍剂量降低,这改善了定量灌注分析。即使在时间样本之间发生显著运动时,PATEN也可用于有效降低图像噪声以提高图像质量。