Ifediora Chris O
School of Medicine, Griffith University, Gold Coast Campus, Parklands Drive, Southport, QLD, 4215, Australia.
BMC Fam Pract. 2016 Jan 13;17:2. doi: 10.1186/s12875-016-0400-8.
No previous study had ever looked at Burnout among medical practitioners involved in after-hours house calls (AHHC) in Australia. The growing popularity of AHHC and the high number of overseas-trained doctors involved in it make this a subject of both local and international significance. This study aims to assess the levels of burnout among Australian-based doctors involved in the service.
This is a quantitative, questionnaire-based survey of all the 300 doctors engaged in AHHC through the National Home Doctor Service (NHDS), Australia's largest home doctor-visit service providers. The study looked at experiences of the participants over the 12-months period from October 2013 to September 2014. The main outcome measure was the 22-item Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI). Results were presented as Means and Frequency Percentages.
A total of 168 valid questionnaires out of 300 were returned, giving a 56.0 % response rate. The Total Maslach Mean Scores (MMS) obtained were 15.97 for Emotional Exhaustion (EE), 3.15 for Depersonalization (DP) and 40.39 for Personal Accomplishment (PA), signifying low-level burnouts in all three dimensions of the MBI. This pattern was equally reflected when the Frequency Percentages were analyzed. With this approach, a majority (56.8%) of the responses were low-level burnout on the EE dimension, while 23.4 and 19.8% respectively reported medium and high level burnouts. On the DP dimension, 87.6, 6.3 and 6.1% of the responses were low, moderate and high level burnouts respectively, while the PA dimension recorded 86.4, 9.6 and 4.0 % respectively. Given that on the MBI scale, perceived personal accomplishment has an inverse relationship with burnout, the low-level MMS finding on the PA dimension therefore indicate a commensurate high perception of personal accomplishments.
Burnout levels are low while perceived achievements are high among doctors involved in after-hours house calls in Australia. The survey recommends that future studies be designed to explore the real reasons behind these findings.
此前尚无研究关注过澳大利亚参与夜间出诊(AHHC)的医生的职业倦怠情况。AHHC越来越受欢迎,且参与其中的海外培训医生数量众多,这使得该研究具有本地和国际意义。本研究旨在评估参与此项服务的澳大利亚医生的职业倦怠水平。
这是一项基于问卷调查的定量研究,对通过澳大利亚最大的上门医疗服务提供商国家家庭医生服务(NHDS)参与AHHC的300名医生进行了调查。该研究考察了参与者在2013年10月至2014年9月这12个月期间的经历。主要结局指标是包含22个条目的马氏职业倦怠量表(MBI)。结果以均值和频率百分比呈现。
300份问卷中共收回168份有效问卷,回复率为56.0%。在MBI的所有三个维度中,情感耗竭(EE)的总马氏平均得分(MMS)为15.97,去个性化(DP)为3.15,个人成就感(PA)为40.39,表明倦怠程度较低。在分析频率百分比时,这种模式也同样得到体现。采用这种方法,在EE维度上,大多数(56.8%)的回复为低水平倦怠,而分别有23.4%和19.8%的回复报告为中等水平和高水平倦怠。在DP维度上,分别有87.6%、6.3%和6.1%的回复为低、中和高水平倦怠,而在PA维度上,分别为86.4%、9.6%和4.0%。鉴于在MBI量表上,个人成就感与职业倦怠呈负相关,因此PA维度上的低水平MMS结果表明个人成就感相应较高。
在澳大利亚参与夜间出诊的医生中,职业倦怠水平较低,而成就感较高。该调查建议未来的研究应旨在探究这些结果背后的真正原因。