MacVicar Ronald, Clarke Gillian, Hogg David R
NHS Education for Scotland, Centre for Health Science, Inverness, Scotland.
University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland.
Rural Remote Health. 2016 Jan-Mar;16(1):3550. Epub 2016 Jan 15.
In Scotland 20% of the population live in a remote or rural area spread across 94% of the land mass that is defined as remote and rural. NHS Education for Scotland (NES), NHS Scotland's training and education body, works in partnership with territorial health boards and medical schools to address rural recruitment and retention through a variety of initiatives. The longest established of these is the GP Rural Fellowship, which has been in place since 2002. This article describes this program and reports on a survey of the output of the Fellowship from 2002 to 2013.
The Fellowship is aimed at newly qualified GPs, who are offered a further year of training in and exposure to rural medicine. The Fellowship has grown and undergone several modifications since its inception. The current model involves co-funding arrangements between NES and participating boards, supporting a maximum of 12 fellows per year. The Health Boards' investment in the Fellowship is returned through the service commitment that the Fellows provide, and the funding share from NES allows Fellows to have protected educational time to meet their educational needs in relation to rural medicine. Given this level of funding support it is important that the outcome of the Fellowship experience is understood, in particular its influence on recruitment to and retention in general practice in rural Scotland. To address this need a survey of all previous rural Fellows was undertaken in the first quarter of 2014, including all Fellows that had undertaken the Fellowship between 2002-03 and 2012-13. A total of 69 GPs were recruited to the Fellowship in this period, of which 66 were able to be included in the survey. There was a response rate of 98% to the survey and 63 of those that responded (97%) were working currently in general practice, 53 of whom were doing so in Scotland. A total of 46 graduates of the Fellowship in the period surveyed (71%) were working in rural areas or accessible small towns in Scotland, 39 in substantive general practice roles (60%).
Scotland's GP Rural Fellowship program represents a successful collaboration between education and service, and the results of the survey reported in this article underline previously unpublished data that suggest that approximately three-quarters of graduates are retained in important roles in rural Scotland. It is unclear however whether the Fellowship confirms a prior intention to work in rural practice, or whether it provides a new opportunity through protected exposure. This will form the basis of further evaluation.
在苏格兰,20%的人口居住在偏远或农村地区,这些地区分布在占陆地面积94%的偏远和农村区域。苏格兰国民保健服务教育机构(NES)是苏格兰国民保健服务体系的培训和教育部门,它与各地区卫生委员会及医学院合作,通过各种举措解决农村地区的人员招聘和留用问题。其中开展时间最长的是全科医生农村奖学金计划,该计划自2002年起实施。本文介绍了该计划,并报告了对2002年至2013年期间该奖学金计划成果的一项调查。
该奖学金计划面向新获得资格的全科医生,为他们提供为期一年的农村医学培训和实践机会。自设立以来,该奖学金计划不断发展并经历了几次调整。目前的模式是NES与参与计划的各委员会共同出资,每年最多支持12名学员。卫生委员会对该奖学金计划的投资通过学员提供的服务承诺得以回报,而NES提供的资金份额使学员有受保护的学习时间来满足他们在农村医学方面的教育需求。鉴于有这样的资金支持,了解该奖学金计划的成果就显得很重要,尤其是其对苏格兰农村地区全科医生招聘和留用的影响。为满足这一需求,2014年第一季度对之前所有农村奖学金学员进行了一项调查,包括2002 - 2003年至2012 - 2013年期间参加该奖学金计划的所有学员。在此期间,共有69名全科医生参加了该奖学金计划,其中66名能够纳入调查。该调查的回复率为98%,回复的人中63人(97%)目前从事全科医疗工作,其中53人在苏格兰工作。在调查期间,该奖学金计划的毕业生中共有46人(71%)在苏格兰农村地区或交通便利的小镇工作,39人担任实质性的全科医疗岗位(60%)。
苏格兰的全科医生农村奖学金计划代表了教育与服务之间的成功合作,本文所报告的调查结果突显了之前未公布的数据,这些数据表明约四分之三的毕业生在苏格兰农村地区担任重要角色。然而,尚不清楚该奖学金计划是确认了学员之前在农村行医的意愿,还是通过提供受保护的实践机会创造了新的机会。这将成为进一步评估的基础。