Rolland Benjamin, Paille François, Gillet Claudine, Rigaud Alain, Moirand Romain, Dano Corine, Dematteis Maurice, Mann Karl, Aubin Henri-Jean
Société Française d'Alcoologie, Issy-les-Moulineaux, France.
Service d'Addictologie, CHRU de Lille, INSERM U1171, Univ Lille, Lille, France.
CNS Neurosci Ther. 2016 Jan;22(1):25-37. doi: 10.1111/cns.12489.
The latest French good practice recommendations (GPRs) for the screening, prevention, and treatment of alcohol misuse were recently published in partnership with the European Federation of Addiction Societies (EUFAS). This article aims to synthesize the GPRs focused on the pharmacotherapy of alcohol dependence.
A four-member European steering committee defined the questions that were addressed to an 18-member multiprofessional working group (WG). The WG developed the GPRs based on a systematic, hierarchical, and structured literature search and submitted the document to two review processes involving 37 French members from multiple disciplines and 5 non-French EUFAS members. The final GPRs were graded A, B, or C, or expert consensus (EC) using a reference recommendation grading system.
The treatment of alcohol dependence consists of either alcohol detoxification or abstinence maintenance programs or drinking reduction programs. The therapeutic objective is the result of a decision made jointly by the physician and the patient. For alcohol detoxification, benzodiazepines (BZDs) are recommended in first-line (grade A). BZD dosing should be guided by regular clinical monitoring (grade B). Residential detoxification is more appropriate for patients with a history of seizures, delirium tremens, unstable psychiatric comorbidity, or another associated substance use disorder (grade B). BZDs are only justified beyond a 1-week period in the case of persistent withdrawal symptoms, withdrawal events or associated BZD dependence (grade B). BZDs should not be continued for more than 4 weeks (grade C). The dosing and duration of thiamine (vitamin B1) during detoxification should be adapted to nutritional status (EC). For relapse prevention, acamprosate and naltrexone are recommended as first-line medications (grade A). Disulfiram can be proposed as second-line option in patients with sufficient information and supervision (EC). For reducing alcohol consumption, nalmefene is indicated in first line (grade A). The second-line prescription of baclofen, up to 300 mg/day, to prevent relapse or reduce drinking should be carried out according to the "temporary recommendation for use" measure issued by the French Health Agency (EC). During pregnancy, abstinence is recommended (EC). If alcohol detoxification is conducted during pregnancy, BZD use is recommended (grade B). No medication other than those for alcohol detoxification should be initiated in pregnant or breastfeeding women (EC). In a stabilized pregnant patient taking medication to support abstinence, the continuation of the drug should be considered on a case-by-case basis, weighing the benefit/risk ratio. Only disulfiram should be always stopped, given the unknown risks of the antabuse effect on the fetus (EC). First-line treatments to help maintain abstinence or reduce drinking are off-label for people under 18 years of age and should thus be considered on a case-by-case basis after the repeated failure of psychosocial measures alone (EC). Short half-life BZDs should be preferred for the detoxification of elderly patients (grade B). The initial doses of BZDs should be reduced by 30 to 50% in elderly patients (EC). In patients with chronic alcohol-related physical disorders, abstinence is recommended (EC). Any antidepressant or anxiolytic medication should be introduced after a psychiatric reassessment after 2-4 weeks of alcohol abstinence or low-risk use (grade B). A smoking cessation program should be offered to any smokers involved in an alcohol treatment program (grade B).
法国最近与欧洲成瘾协会联合会(EUFAS)合作发布了关于酒精滥用筛查、预防和治疗的最新良好实践建议(GPRs)。本文旨在综合聚焦于酒精依赖药物治疗的GPRs。
一个由四名成员组成的欧洲指导委员会确定了向一个由18名成员组成的多专业工作组(WG)提出的问题。该工作组基于系统、分层和结构化的文献检索制定了GPRs,并将文件提交给两个评审过程,涉及来自多个学科的37名法国成员和5名非法国EUFAS成员。最终的GPRs使用参考推荐分级系统分为A、B或C级,或专家共识(EC)。
酒精依赖的治疗包括酒精脱毒、戒酒维持计划或减少饮酒计划。治疗目标是医生和患者共同做出的决定的结果。对于酒精脱毒,一线推荐使用苯二氮䓬类药物(BZDs)(A级)。BZD给药应通过定期临床监测来指导(B级)。住院脱毒更适合有癫痫发作史、震颤谵妄、不稳定的精神合并症或其他相关物质使用障碍的患者(B级)。仅在持续戒断症状、戒断事件或相关BZD依赖的情况下,BZDs在超过1周的时间内使用才合理(B级)。BZDs不应持续使用超过4周(C级)。脱毒期间硫胺素(维生素B1)的给药剂量和持续时间应根据营养状况进行调整(EC)。对于预防复发,阿坎酸和纳曲酮被推荐作为一线药物(A级)。在有充分信息和监督的患者中,双硫仑可作为二线选择提出(EC)。为了减少酒精消费,纳美芬被列为一线用药(A级)。应根据法国卫生机构发布的“临时使用建议”措施,开具最高剂量为每日300毫克的巴氯芬二线处方,以预防复发或减少饮酒(EC)。怀孕期间,建议戒酒(EC)。如果在怀孕期间进行酒精脱毒,建议使用BZD(B级)。怀孕或哺乳期妇女不应开始使用除酒精脱毒药物以外的任何药物(EC)。对于正在服用支持戒酒药物的稳定孕妇,应逐案考虑药物的继续使用,权衡利弊。鉴于双硫仑对胎儿的戒酒硫样作用风险未知,应始终停用双硫仑(EC)。帮助维持戒酒或减少饮酒的一线治疗方法对18岁以下人群属于超说明书用药,因此应在仅采取心理社会措施反复失败后逐案考虑(EC)。老年患者脱毒时应首选短效BZDs(B级)。老年患者BZDs的初始剂量应减少30%至50%(EC)。对于患有慢性酒精相关身体疾病的患者,建议戒酒(EC)。在戒酒或低风险使用酒精2 - 4周后进行精神科重新评估后,才可引入任何抗抑郁药或抗焦虑药(B级)。应为参与酒精治疗计划的任何吸烟者提供戒烟计划(B级)。