Manne Sharon L, Topham Neal, Kirstein Laurie, Virtue Shannon Myers, Brill Kristin, Devine Katie A, Gajda Tina, Frederick Sara, Darabos Katie, Sorice Kristen
Author Affiliations: Section of Population Science, Department of Medicine, Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Rutgers, the Cancer Institute of New Jersey, New Brunswick (Drs Manne, Kirstein, Myers Virtue, and Devine and Mss Gajda, Frederick, and Darabos); Cancer Prevention and Control Program, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (Dr Topham); MD Anderson Cancer Center at Cooper Health Systems, Voorhees Township, New Jersey (Dr Brill); and Department of Surgery, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (Ms Sorice).
Cancer Nurs. 2016 Nov/Dec;39(6):427-436. doi: 10.1097/NCC.0000000000000320.
The decision to undergo breast reconstruction (BR) surgery after mastectomy is made during stressful circumstances. Many women do not feel well prepared to make this decision.
Using the Ottawa Decision Support Framework, this study aims to describe women's reasons to choose or not choose BR, BR knowledge, decisional preparedness, and decisional conflict about BR. Possible demographic, medical, BR knowledge, and attitudinal correlates of decisional conflict about BR were also evaluated.
Participants were 55 women with early-stage breast cancer drawn from the baseline data of a pilot randomized trial evaluating the efficacy of a BR decision support aid for breast cancer patients considering BR.
The most highly ranked reasons to choose BR were the desire for breasts to be equal in size, the desire to wake up from surgery with a breast in place, and perceived bother of a scar with no breast. The most highly ranked reasons not to choose BR were related to the surgical risks and complications. Regression analyses indicated that decisional conflict was associated with higher number of reasons not to choose BR and lower levels of decisional preparedness.
The results suggest that breast cancer patients considering BR may benefit from decisional support.
Healthcare professionals may facilitate decision making by focusing on reasons for each patient's uncertainty and unaddressed concerns. All patients, even those who have consulted with a plastic surgeon and remain uncertain about their decision, may benefit from decision support from a health professional.
乳房切除术后进行乳房重建(BR)手术的决定是在压力环境下做出的。许多女性觉得自己没有做好做出这个决定的准备。
本研究使用渥太华决策支持框架,旨在描述女性选择或不选择BR的原因、BR知识、决策准备情况以及关于BR的决策冲突。还评估了与BR决策冲突可能相关的人口统计学、医学、BR知识和态度因素。
参与者为55名早期乳腺癌女性,数据来自一项评估BR决策支持辅助工具对考虑进行BR的乳腺癌患者疗效的试点随机试验的基线数据。
选择BR的最主要原因是希望两侧乳房大小相等、希望术后醒来时乳房还在原位以及认为没有乳房的疤痕很麻烦。不选择BR的最主要原因与手术风险和并发症有关。回归分析表明,决策冲突与不选择BR的原因数量较多以及决策准备水平较低有关。
结果表明,考虑进行BR的乳腺癌患者可能从决策支持中受益。
医疗保健专业人员可以通过关注每位患者不确定性和未解决担忧的原因来促进决策制定。所有患者,即使是那些已经咨询过整形外科医生但仍对自己的决定不确定的患者,都可能从医疗专业人员的决策支持中受益。