Reidy Dennis E, Kearns Megan C, Houry Debra, Valle Linda A, Holland Kristin M, Marshall Khiya J
Division of Violence Prevention and
Division of Violence Prevention and.
Pediatrics. 2016 Feb;137(2):e20152627. doi: 10.1542/peds.2015-2627. Epub 2016 Jan 29.
To assess gender differences in the proportion of adolescents reporting teen dating violence (TDV) and the frequency of TDV at multiple age points across adolescence in a high-risk sample of youth with previous exposure to violence.
A cross-sectional, high-risk sample of boys and girls (n = 1149) ages 11 to 17 years completed surveys assessing TDV and self-defense. Indices of TDV included perpetration and victimization scales of controlling behaviors, psychological TDV, physical TDV, sexual TDV, fear/intimidation, and injury.
More girls reported perpetrating psychological and physical TDV, whereas twice as many boys reported sexual TDV perpetration. More girls reported fear/intimidation victimization than boys. When comparing the frequency of TDV across adolescence, boys reported more sexual TDV victimization at younger ages, and girls demonstrated a trend toward more victimization at older ages. Likewise, younger boys reported more fear/intimidation and injury perpetration and injury victimization than younger girls. However, by age 17, girls reported more injury perpetration than boys, and reports of injury victimization and use of self-defense did not differ. Notably, despite potential parity in injury, girls consistently reported more fear/intimidation victimization associated with TDV.
Contrary to data suggesting that girls experience far more sexual TDV and injury, these data suggest that at specific times during adolescence, boys among high-risk populations may be equally at risk for victimization. However, the psychological consequences (fear) are greater for girls. These findings suggest a need to tailor strategies to prevent TDV based on both age- and gender-specific characteristics in high-risk populations.
在曾遭受暴力的高风险青年样本中,评估青少年报告青少年恋爱暴力(TDV)的比例及整个青春期多个年龄点的TDV发生频率的性别差异。
对11至17岁的男孩和女孩(n = 1149)进行横断面高风险抽样,让他们完成评估TDV和自卫情况的调查。TDV指标包括控制行为、心理TDV、身体TDV、性TDV、恐惧/恐吓及伤害的实施和受害量表。
更多女孩报告实施心理和身体TDV,而报告实施性TDV的男孩数量是女孩的两倍。报告恐惧/恐吓受害的女孩比男孩更多。在比较整个青春期的TDV发生频率时,男孩在较年轻时报告的性TDV受害情况更多,而女孩在较年长时呈现出受害情况增多的趋势。同样,较年轻的男孩报告的恐惧/恐吓及伤害实施情况和伤害受害情况比年轻女孩更多。然而,到17岁时,女孩报告的伤害实施情况比男孩更多,且伤害受害情况和自卫使用情况的报告没有差异。值得注意的是,尽管在伤害方面可能相当,但女孩始终报告与TDV相关的恐惧/恐吓受害情况更多。
与表明女孩遭受更多性TDV和伤害的数据相反,这些数据表明,在青春期的特定时期,高风险人群中的男孩可能同样面临受害风险。然而,女孩的心理后果(恐惧)更大。这些发现表明需要根据高风险人群中特定年龄和性别的特征制定预防TDV的策略。