Rosenthal M J
University of Illinois, College of Medicine, Chicago.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1989 Sep;80(3):207-15. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1989.tb01329.x.
Performance of mental status examinations (MSE) is often useful but is not warranted for all new patients, except for training, research, special request, or policy. Reasons for doing MSE must be weighed against possible detrimental effects on patients or on patient-clinician relationships. Both sides are reviewed. Methods for ameliorating or preventing adverse effects are described. Validity of findings using MSE are frequently doubtful and examiners often misinterpret their significance. A decision tree is presented to help decide whether to use the MSE in particular instances.
进行精神状态检查(MSE)通常是有用的,但并非适用于所有新患者,培训、研究、特殊要求或政策情况除外。进行MSE的理由必须与对患者或医患关系可能产生的不利影响相权衡。本文对这两方面都进行了探讨。文中还描述了改善或预防不良影响的方法。使用MSE得出的结果的有效性常常存疑,检查者也常常误解其意义。本文提供了一个决策树,以帮助决定在特定情况下是否使用MSE。