Menezes Audrey, Burgess Annette, Clarke Antonia J, Mellis Craig
Central Clinical School, Sydney Medical School, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia; Hornsby Ku-ring-gai Hospital, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Central Clinical School, Sydney Medical School, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2016 Jan 18;7:31-8. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S94570. eCollection 2016.
Peer tutoring offers a valuable method of enhancing students' learning experience in medical school. Junior students learn from senior peers to reinforce curriculum content in an engaging community environment. The aim of our study was to assess tutees' perceptions of a formal peer tutoring program at the Central Clinical School of Sydney Medical School. We used the learning theory of the community of practice in order to understand tutees' perspectives.
All Year 1 and Year 2 students within the Central Clinical School were invited to be tutored by Year 3 and Year 4 students, respectively. Tutor pairs taught a group of three to four tutees fortnightly, and the tutorials were largely clinically based. A questionnaire containing 13 closed items and four open-ended questions regarding their experiences in the program was distributed to the tutees. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze the data.
A total of 66 of 101 (65%) Year 1 and Year 2 students took part as tutees and 42 of 106 (40%) students as tutors. The tutees' response rate was 53% (35/66). Results were largely positive, with 97% of the tutees enjoying the program, 90% showing interest in tutorial topics, 91% feeling a sense of community, 100% wanting to take part next year, 97% finding small groups effective, and 97% and 91% feeling an improved understanding of medical concepts and clinical skills, respectively. Tutees perceived the most useful aspects to be learning and revision and advice from experienced peers. The most frequent suggestion for improvement was to resolve scheduling conflicts.
Tutees found the peer tutoring program to be valuable in learning and revision, establishing a community, and gaining practical skills and advice through a small-group format. The community of practice framework was useful in identifying these areas of benefit, demonstrating that a peer tutoring program such as this can provide an enhanced learning environment for tutees.
同伴辅导为提升医学院学生的学习体验提供了一种有价值的方法。低年级学生向高年级同伴学习,在一个引人入胜的社区环境中强化课程内容。我们研究的目的是评估悉尼医学院中央临床学院学生对正式同伴辅导项目的看法。我们运用实践共同体的学习理论来理解受辅导学生的观点。
中央临床学院所有一年级和二年级学生分别被邀请由三年级和四年级学生进行辅导。辅导小组每两周对一组三到四名受辅导学生进行授课,辅导课程主要以临床为基础。向受辅导学生发放了一份包含13个封闭式问题和4个关于他们在该项目中经历的开放式问题的问卷。采用描述性统计分析数据。
101名一年级和二年级学生中有66名(65%)作为受辅导学生参与,106名学生中有42名(40%)作为辅导学生参与。受辅导学生的回复率为53%(35/66)。结果总体呈积极态势,97%的受辅导学生喜欢该项目,90%对辅导主题感兴趣,91%有社区感,100%希望明年继续参与,97%认为小组辅导有效,97%和91%分别感觉对医学概念和临床技能的理解有所提高。受辅导学生认为最有用的方面是学习、复习以及从有经验的同伴那里获得建议。最常见的改进建议是解决日程安排冲突。
受辅导学生发现同伴辅导项目在学习、复习、建立社区以及通过小组形式获得实践技能和建议方面很有价值。实践共同体框架有助于识别这些受益领域,表明这样的同伴辅导项目可以为受辅导学生提供一个更好的学习环境。