Zheng Binbin, Wang Zilu
Bau Institute of Medical and Health Sciences Education, Li Ka Shing Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
PLoS One. 2022 Dec 14;17(12):e0278256. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0278256. eCollection 2022.
This study explores how tutors and tutees perceived their teaching and learning experience in a near-peer teaching programme within a formal undergraduate medical-education curriculum.
This mixed-methods study was conducted in an Asian medical school. First, a survey was administered to two groups of students, one that had been tutored by near-peers, and another with faculty tutors. Then, the near-peer tutors were interviewed and wrote reflection essays that the researchers collected. Quantitative analysis was used to analyse the survey responses, and qualitative analysis to analyse the interview and reflection data.
Our study found no difference between near-peer tutees' and faculty tutees' perceptions of either tutor facilitation or tutor behaviours. Also, when near-peer tutors explained how their experience of delivering tutoring had influenced their professional-identity formation, they highlighted that they had gained skills important to their future careers as medical educators.
Integrating near-peer teaching into undergraduate medical curricula could be beneficial to both tutors and tutees because of the social, cognitive, and professional congruence between these two groups, and due to its likely positive influence on their professional-identity formation.
本研究探讨了在本科医学教育正式课程中的近同伴教学项目里,辅导教师和学生如何看待他们的教与学体验。
这项混合方法研究在一所亚洲医学院开展。首先,对两组学生进行了调查,一组由近同伴辅导,另一组由教师辅导。然后,对近同伴辅导教师进行了访谈,并收集了他们撰写的反思文章。定量分析用于分析调查回复,定性分析用于分析访谈和反思数据。
我们的研究发现,近同伴辅导的学生和教师辅导的学生在对辅导教师的引导作用或行为的看法上没有差异。此外,当近同伴辅导教师解释他们的辅导经历如何影响其职业身份形成时,他们强调自己获得了对未来作为医学教育工作者的职业发展很重要的技能。
将近同伴教学纳入本科医学课程可能对辅导教师和学生都有益,这是因为这两组人员在社会、认知和专业方面具有一致性,并且它可能对他们的职业身份形成产生积极影响。