Ramanathan Tara
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Clin Gov. 2014;19(2):172-180. doi: 10.1108/CGIJ-03-2014-0015.
The purpose of this paper is to inform healthcare providers and healthcare facility leadership about the statutory, administrative, criminal, and tort law implications related to preventable harms from unsafe injection practices.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: Review of legal theory and precedents.
The law can address disputes over unsafe injection practices in a variety of ways. Administrative agencies may hold a provider or facility responsible for preventable harms according to specific statutory and regulatory provisions governing licensure. State courts can compensate victims of certain actions or inactions based on tort law, where a breach of a legal duty caused damages. Prosecutors and the public can turn to criminal law to punish defendants and deter future actions that result in disability or death.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS/IMPLICATIONS: The state law findings in this review are limited to legal provisions and court cases that are available on searchable databases. Due to the nature of this topic, many cases are settled out of court, and those records are sealed from the public and not available for review.
Preventable harm continues to occur from unsafe injection practices. These practices pose a significant risk of disease or even death for patients and could result in legal repercussions for healthcare providers and facility leadership.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: This article reviews emerging law and potential legal implications for health care and public health related to unsafe medical practices related to needle, syringe, and vial use.
本文旨在让医疗服务提供者和医疗机构领导层了解与不安全注射操作导致的可预防伤害相关的法定、行政、刑事和侵权法影响。
设计/方法/途径:对法律理论和先例进行回顾。
法律可以通过多种方式解决与不安全注射操作有关的纠纷。行政机构可根据有关许可的具体法规,要求提供者或机构对可预防的伤害负责。州法院可根据侵权法对某些作为或不作为的受害者进行赔偿,即违反法定义务造成损害的情况。检察官和公众可诉诸刑法来惩罚被告,并威慑未来导致残疾或死亡的行为。
研究局限性/影响:本综述中的州法律研究结果仅限于可搜索数据库中可得的法律条文和法院案例。由于该主题的性质,许多案件在庭外和解,这些记录对公众保密,无法查阅。
不安全注射操作继续导致可预防的伤害。这些操作给患者带来了重大的疾病甚至死亡风险,并可能给医疗服务提供者和机构领导层带来法律后果。
原创性/价值:本文回顾了与针头、注射器和药瓶使用相关的不安全医疗操作对医疗保健和公共卫生产生的新兴法律及潜在法律影响。