Drabble Laurie, Trocki Karen F, Klinger Jamie L
San José State University School of Social Work, One Washington Square, San José, CA 95192-0124, United States.
Alcohol Research Group, Public Health Institute, 6475 Christie Ave. Suite 400, Emeryville, CA 94608, United States.
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2016 Apr 1;161:127-34. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2016.01.022. Epub 2016 Feb 2.
Despite research documenting disparities in risk for alcohol-related problems among sexual minority women, few studies explore potential protective factors within this population. This study examines how religiosity may function as a protective or risk factor for alcohol-problems or other substance use among sexual minorities compared to heterosexuals.
Data from 11,169 women who responded to sexual identity and sexual behavior questions from three population-based National Alcohol Survey waves (2000, 2005, 2010) were utilized for analyses of religiosity in relation to lifetime drinking, past year hazardous drinking, and past year drug use.
Religiosity was significantly greater among exclusively heterosexual women compared to all sexual minority groups (lesbian, bisexual and heterosexual women who report same sex partners). Lesbians reported the lowest rates of affiliation with religions/denominations discouraging alcohol use. Past year hazardous drinking and use of any illicit drugs were significantly lower among exclusively heterosexual women compared to all sexual minority groups. High religiosity was associated with lifetime alcohol abstention and was found to be protective against hazardous drinking and drug use among both sexual minority and heterosexual women. Reporting religious norms unfavorable to drinking was protective against hazardous drinking among exclusively heterosexual women but not sexual minority women.
Findings reveal the importance of considering sexual minority status in evaluation of religion or spirituality as protective among women. Future studies should explore religiosity in the context of other individual and environmental factors, such as positive identity development and community-level acceptance, which may be salient to resiliency among sexual minorities.
尽管有研究记录了性少数群体女性在酒精相关问题风险上的差异,但很少有研究探讨该群体内部的潜在保护因素。本研究考察了与异性恋者相比,宗教信仰如何作为性少数群体中酒精问题或其他物质使用的保护因素或风险因素发挥作用。
利用来自三次基于人群的全国酒精调查(2000年、2005年、2010年)中11169名回答了性取向和性行为问题的女性的数据,分析宗教信仰与终生饮酒、过去一年危险饮酒及过去一年药物使用之间的关系。
与所有性少数群体(女同性恋者、双性恋者以及报告有同性伴侣的异性恋女性)相比,完全异性恋女性的宗教信仰程度显著更高。女同性恋者报告称,与那些不鼓励饮酒的宗教/教派的隶属率最低。与所有性少数群体相比,完全异性恋女性过去一年的危险饮酒和任何非法药物使用显著更低。高宗教信仰与终生戒酒有关,并且被发现对性少数群体和异性恋女性的危险饮酒和药物使用均有保护作用。报告不利于饮酒的宗教规范对完全异性恋女性的危险饮酒有保护作用,但对性少数群体女性则不然。
研究结果揭示了在评估宗教或精神信仰对女性的保护作用时考虑性少数群体身份的重要性。未来的研究应在其他个体和环境因素的背景下探索宗教信仰,如积极的身份发展和社区层面的接纳,这些因素可能对性少数群体的复原力很重要。