Black F L
Prog Med Virol. 1989;36:1-33.
'The simplest of all virus disease is measles' said Kenneth Maxy 40 years ago in a chapter on epidemiology. I hope that the data set out here provide the reader with a sufficiently complete and clear picture of the factors that determine measles epidemiology, that he or she will agree with Maxy's prescient words. Measles is an antigenically complex virus, but few components of the immune response to this virus are epidemiologically relevant. The relevant components are durable for a lifetime. They can be conveniently measured by serological tests, and the results of these tests correlate well with measles immunity. The tests show that measles is an extremely infectious disease, and that very high antibody prevalence rates are needed for herd protection. The currently available measles vaccine is capable of yielding adequate antibody prevalence rates for herd immunity, but to achieve this, immunization procedural flaws and faulty records must be kept to very low levels. The greatest obstacle to worldwide control of measles is a failure of vaccination programs to produce adequate herd immunity levels in less-developed countries. There, vaccine must be given promptly after passive immunity wanes, because the level of endemicity is so high. It is difficult to determine just what age is optimal, because it varies from one country to another. Premature vaccination not only fails to immunize, but also interferes with subsequent re-immunization. Because we now know this, further direct tests of vaccine effectiveness in very young children are ethically undesirable, and methods that use determination of passively acquired antibody are to be preferred. The levels of antibody that mothers have to pass to their children vary considerably. These differences are important in comparisons of South Asian countries with others, but not elsewhere. Differences in efficiency of transport of antibody across the placenta also play a role, but usually a minor one. Most important seems to be variation in antibody durability in the infant. Where families are poor, the children acquire many infections at an early age, and passively acquired antibody is swept out. These children who are least able to withstand the effects of measles infection, are hit at the earliest age. To provide protection for them, the vaccine must be given at a carefully determined age, specific for each community. Only when this is done can we hope to reduce measles worldwide to a sufficiently low level that it will be removed as a threat to persons in the United States, or anywhere else.
40年前,肯尼斯·马克西在一章关于流行病学的内容中写道:“所有病毒疾病中最简单的就是麻疹。”我希望这里列出的数据能为读者提供一幅足够完整和清晰的画面,展示决定麻疹流行病学的因素,使读者认同马克西具有先见之明的这番话。麻疹是一种抗原复杂的病毒,但针对这种病毒的免疫反应中,与流行病学相关的成分很少。这些相关成分能终生保持。它们可以通过血清学检测方便地进行测量,而且这些检测结果与麻疹免疫力密切相关。检测表明麻疹是一种极具传染性的疾病,需要非常高的抗体流行率才能实现群体免疫。目前可用的麻疹疫苗能够产生足够的抗体流行率以实现群体免疫,但要做到这一点,免疫程序缺陷和记录错误必须保持在极低水平。全球控制麻疹的最大障碍是在欠发达国家,疫苗接种计划未能产生足够的群体免疫水平。在这些国家,被动免疫减弱后必须立即接种疫苗,因为地方流行程度很高。很难确定究竟什么年龄是最佳的,因为这因国家而异。过早接种疫苗不仅无法产生免疫效果,还会干扰后续的再次接种。因为我们现在知道了这一点,所以从伦理角度来看,在非常年幼的儿童中进一步直接测试疫苗效果是不可取的,而采用检测被动获得抗体的方法更可取。母亲传递给孩子的抗体水平差异很大。这些差异在南亚国家与其他国家的比较中很重要,但在其他地方并非如此。抗体通过胎盘转运效率的差异也起作用,但通常是次要作用。最重要的似乎是婴儿体内抗体持久性的差异。在家庭贫困的地方,儿童在幼年时会感染许多疾病,被动获得的抗体就会被清除。这些最无法抵御麻疹感染影响的儿童,在最早的年龄就会受到侵袭。为了保护他们,必须在为每个社区精心确定的特定年龄接种疫苗。只有这样做,我们才有希望将全球麻疹发病率降低到足够低的水平,使其不再成为对美国或其他任何地方的人们的威胁。