McCrink Koleen, Shafto Patrick, Barth Hilary
a Psychology Department , Barnard College, Columbia University , New York , NY , USA.
b Department of Mathematics and Computer Science , Rutgers University , Newark , NJ , USA.
Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2017 Apr;70(4):686-702. doi: 10.1080/17470218.2016.1151060. Epub 2016 Mar 8.
Children without formal education in addition and subtraction are able to perform multi-step operations over an approximate number of objects. Further, their performance improves when solving approximate (but not exact) addition and subtraction problems that allow for inversion as a shortcut (e.g., a + b - b = a). The current study examines children's ability to perform multi-step operations, and the potential for an inversion benefit, for the operations of approximate, non-symbolic multiplication and division. Children were trained to compute a multiplication and division scaling factor (2 or /2, 4 or /4), and were then tested on problems that combined two of these factors in a way that either allowed for an inversion shortcut (e.g., 84/4) or did not (e.g., 84/2). Children's performance was significantly better than chance for all scaling factors during training, and they successfully computed the outcomes of the multi-step testing problems. They did not exhibit a performance benefit for problems with the a*b/b structure, suggesting that they did not draw upon inversion reasoning as a logical shortcut to help them solve the multi-step test problems.
未接受过加减法正规教育的儿童能够对大约数量的物体进行多步运算。此外,当他们解决允许使用倒数作为捷径的近似(而非精确)加减法问题时(例如,a + b - b = a),其表现会有所提高。当前研究考察了儿童进行多步运算的能力,以及在近似、非符号乘除法运算中利用倒数优势的可能性。对儿童进行了计算乘除法缩放因子(2或/2,4或/4)的训练,然后让他们对以允许使用倒数捷径(例如,84/4)或不允许使用倒数捷径(例如,84/2)的方式组合两个此类因子的问题进行测试。在训练过程中,儿童对于所有缩放因子的表现都显著优于随机水平,并且他们成功计算出了多步测试问题的结果。他们在具有a*b/b结构的问题上并未表现出优势,这表明他们没有将倒数推理作为一种逻辑捷径来帮助自己解决多步测试问题。