Levine Stephen Z, Levav Itzhak, Yoffe Rinat, Becher Yifat, Pugachova Inna
Department of Community Mental Health, Faculty of Social Welfare and Health Sciences, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel.
Department of Information and Evaluation, Ministry of Health, Jerusalem, Israel.
PLoS One. 2016 Feb 22;11(2):e0149524. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0149524. eCollection 2016.
The association between periods of genocide-related exposures and suicide risk remains unknown. Our study tests that association using a national population-based study design. The source population comprised of all persons born during1922-1945 in Nazi-occupied or dominated European nations, that immigrated to Israel by 1965, were identified in the Population Register (N = 220,665), and followed up for suicide to 2014, totaling 16,953,602 person-years. The population was disaggregated to compare a trauma gradient among groups that immigrated before (indirect, n = 20,612, 9%); during (partial direct, n = 17,037, 8%); or after (full direct, n = 183,016, 83%) exposure to the Nazi era. Also, the direct exposure groups were examined regarding pre- or post-natal exposure periods. Cox regression models were used to compute Hazard Ratios (HR) of suicide risk to compare the exposure groups, adjusting for confounding by gender, residential SES and history of psychiatric hospitalization. In the total population, only the partial direct exposure subgroup was at greater risk compared to the indirect exposure group (HR = 1.73, 95% CI, 1.10, 2.73; P < .05). That effect replicated in six sensitivity analyses. In addition, sensitivity analyses showed that exposure at ages 13 plus among females, and follow-up by years since immigration were associated with a greater risk; whereas in utero exposure among persons with no psychiatric hospitalization and early postnatal exposure among males were at a reduced risk. Tentative mechanisms impute biopsychosocial vulnerability and natural selection during early critical periods among males, and feelings of guilt and entrapment or defeat among females.
与种族灭绝相关的暴露时期与自杀风险之间的关联尚不清楚。我们的研究采用基于全国人口的研究设计来检验这种关联。源人群包括1922年至1945年期间在纳粹占领或统治的欧洲国家出生、于1965年前移民到以色列的所有人,这些人在人口登记册中被识别出来(N = 220,665),并随访至2014年的自杀情况,总计16,953,602人年。对人群进行分类,以比较在纳粹时代暴露之前(间接暴露,n = 20,612,9%)、期间(部分直接暴露,n = 17,037,8%)或之后(完全直接暴露,n = 183,016,83%)移民的群体之间的创伤梯度。此外,还对直接暴露组的产前或产后暴露时期进行了检查。使用Cox回归模型计算自杀风险的风险比(HR),以比较暴露组,并对性别、居住社会经济地位和精神科住院史等混杂因素进行调整。在总人口中,只有部分直接暴露亚组与间接暴露组相比风险更高(HR = 1.73,95% CI,1.10,2.73;P <.05)。该效应在六项敏感性分析中得到重复。此外,敏感性分析表明,13岁及以上女性的暴露以及自移民以来的随访时间与更高风险相关;而在没有精神科住院史的人群中,子宫内暴露以及男性的产后早期暴露风险降低。初步机制认为,男性在早期关键时期存在生物心理社会脆弱性和自然选择,而女性则存在内疚、陷入困境或失败感。