Na Hyuntae, Song Guang, ben-Avraham Daniel
Department of Computer Science, Iowa State University, 226 Atanasoff Hall, Ames, Iowa 50011, USA.
Phys Biol. 2016 Feb 23;13(1):016008. doi: 10.1088/1478-3975/13/1/016008.
It is shown that the density of modes of the vibrational spectrum of globular proteins is universal, i.e. regardless of the protein in question, it closely follows one universal curve. The present study, including 135 proteins analyzed with a full atomic empirical potential (CHARMM22) and using the full complement of all atoms Cartesian degrees of freedom, goes far beyond previous claims of universality, confirming that universality holds even in the frequency range that is well above 100 cm(-1) (300-4000 cm(-1)), where peaks and turns in the density of states are faithfully reproduced from one protein to the next. We also characterize fluctuations of the spectral density from the average, paving the way to a meaningful discussion of rare, unusual spectra and the structural reasons for the deviations in such 'outlier' proteins. Since the method used for the derivation of the vibrational modes (potential energy formulation, set of degrees of freedom employed, etc) has a dramatic effect on the spectral density, another significant implication of our findings is that the universality can provide an exquisite tool for assessing and improving the quality of potential functions and the quality of various models used for NMA computations. Finally, we show that the input configuration also affects the density of modes, thus emphasizing the importance of simplified potential energy formulations that are minimized at the outset. In summary, our findings call for a serious two-way dialogue between theory and experiment: experimental spectra of proteins could now guide the fine tuning of theoretical empirical potentials, and the various features and peaks observed in theoretical studies--being universal, and hence now rising in importance--would hopefully spur experimental confirmation.
结果表明,球状蛋白质振动光谱的模式密度具有普遍性,即无论所讨论的蛋白质是什么,其都紧密遵循一条通用曲线。本研究涵盖了135种蛋白质,使用全原子经验势(CHARMM22)并利用笛卡尔坐标系下所有原子的全部自由度进行分析,远远超越了先前关于普遍性的论断,证实了即使在远高于100厘米-1(300 - 4000厘米-1)的频率范围内普遍性依然成立,在该频率范围内,态密度的峰值和转折点能在不同蛋白质之间得到准确再现。我们还对光谱密度相对于平均值的波动进行了表征,为有意义地讨论罕见、异常光谱以及此类“异常值”蛋白质偏差的结构原因铺平了道路。由于用于推导振动模式的方法(势能公式、所采用的自由度集等)对光谱密度有显著影响,我们研究结果的另一个重要意义在于,普遍性可为评估和改进势能函数的质量以及用于非谐性分子动力学计算的各种模型的质量提供一个精妙的工具。最后,我们表明输入构型也会影响模式密度,从而强调了从一开始就将简化势能公式最小化的重要性。总之,我们的研究结果呼吁理论与实验之间进行严肃的双向对话:蛋白质的实验光谱现在可以指导理论经验势的微调,而理论研究中观察到的各种特征和峰值——具有普遍性,因此现在重要性日益增加——有望促使实验得到证实。