Yoganathan S A, Maria Das K J, Mohamed Ali Shajahan, Agarwal Arpita, Mishra Surendra P, Kumar Shaleen
1 Deparment of Radiotherapy, Sanjay Gandhi Post-graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
2 Department of Radiation Oncology, Dr Ram Manohar Lohia Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Br J Radiol. 2016;89(1060):20150870. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20150870. Epub 2016 Feb 26.
The purpose of this work was to evaluate the four-dimensional cone beam CT (4DCBCT) imaging with different gantry rotation speed.
All the 4DCBCT image acquisitions were carried out in Elekta XVI Symmetry™ system (Elekta AB, Stockholm, Sweden). A dynamic thorax phantom with tumour mimicking inserts of diameter 1, 2 and 3 cm was programmed to simulate the respiratory motion (4 s) of the target. 4DCBCT images were acquired with different gantry rotation speeds (36°, 50°, 75°, 100°, 150° and 200° min(-1)). Owing to the technical limitation of 4DCBCT system, average cone beam CT (CBCT) images derived from the 10 phases of 4DCBCT were used for the internal target volume (ITV) contouring. ITVs obtained from average CBCT were compared with the four-dimensional CT (4DCT). In addition, the image quality of 4DCBCT was also evaluated for various gantry rotation speeds using Catphan(®) 600 (The Phantom Laboratory Inc., Salem, NY).
Compared to 4DCT, the average CBCT underestimated the ITV. The ITV deviation increased with increasing gantry speed (-10.8% vs -17.8% for 36° and 200° min(-1) in 3-cm target) and decreasing target size (-17.8% vs -26.8% for target diameter 3 and 1 cm in 200° min(-1)). Similarly, the image quality indicators such as spatial resolution, contrast-to-noise ratio and uniformity also degraded with increasing gantry rotation speed.
The impact of gantry rotation speed has to be considered when using 4DCBCT for ITV definition. The phantom study demonstrated that 4DCBCT with slow gantry rotation showed better image quality and less ITV deviation.
Usually, the gantry rotation period of Elekta 4DCBCT system is kept constant at 4 min (50° min(-1)) for acquisition, and any attempt of decreasing/increasing the acquisition duration requires careful investigation. In this study, the 4DCBCT images with different gantry rotation speed were evaluated.
本研究旨在评估不同机架旋转速度下的四维锥形束CT(4DCBCT)成像。
所有4DCBCT图像采集均在Elekta XVI Symmetry™系统(瑞典斯德哥尔摩的Elekta AB公司)中进行。使用一个带有模拟直径为1、2和3 cm肿瘤的插入物的动态胸部体模来模拟目标的呼吸运动(4 s)。以不同的机架旋转速度(36°、50°、75°、100°、150°和200°·min⁻¹)采集4DCBCT图像。由于4DCBCT系统的技术限制,从4DCBCT的10个相位获得的平均锥形束CT(CBCT)图像用于勾画内部靶区(ITV)。将从平均CBCT获得的ITV与四维CT(4DCT)进行比较。此外,还使用Catphan® 600(纽约塞勒姆的The Phantom Laboratory Inc.公司)评估了不同机架旋转速度下4DCBCT的图像质量。
与4DCT相比,平均CBCT低估了ITV。ITV偏差随着机架速度的增加(在3 cm靶区中,36°和200°·min⁻¹时分别为-10.8%和-17.8%)和靶区尺寸的减小(在200°·min⁻¹时,靶直径为3 cm和1 cm时分别为-17.8%和-26.8%)而增加。同样,图像质量指标如空间分辨率、对比度噪声比和均匀性也随着机架旋转速度的增加而下降。
在使用4DCBCT进行ITV定义时,必须考虑机架旋转速度的影响。体模研究表明,机架旋转速度慢的4DCBCT显示出更好的图像质量和更小的ITV偏差。
通常,Elekta 4DCBCT系统的机架旋转周期在采集时保持恒定为4分钟(50°·min⁻¹),任何缩短/延长采集持续时间的尝试都需要仔细研究。在本研究中,评估了不同机架旋转速度下的4DCBCT图像。