Damant Jacqueline, Knapp Martin, Freddolino Paul, Lombard Daniel
Personal Social Services Research Unit, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK.
School of Social Work, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, USA.
Health Soc Care Community. 2017 Nov;25(6):1679-1703. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12335. Epub 2016 Feb 25.
It is often asserted that older people's quality of life (QOL) is improved when they adopt information and communication technology (ICT) such as the Internet, mobile phones and computers. Similar assumptions are made about older people's use of ICT-based care such as telecare and telehealth. To examine the evidence around these claims, we conducted a scoping review of the academic and grey literature, coving the period between January 2007 and August 2014. A framework analysis approach, based on six domains of QOL derived from the ASCOT and WHOQOL models, was adopted to deductively code and analyse relevant literature. The review revealed mixed results. Older people's use of ICT in both mainstream and care contexts has been shown to have both positive and negative impacts on several aspects of QOL. Studies which have rigorously assessed the impact of older people's use of ICT on their QOL mostly demonstrate little effect. A number of qualitative studies have reported on the positive effects for older people who use ICT such as email or Skype to keep in touch with family and friends. Overall, the review unearthed several inconsistencies around the effects of older people's ICT use on their QOL, suggesting that implicit agreement is needed on the best research methods and instrumentation to adequately describe older people's experiences in today's digital age. Moreover, the available evidence does not consider the large number of older people who do not use ICT and how non-use affects QOL.
人们常常断言,当老年人采用互联网、手机和电脑等信息通信技术(ICT)时,他们的生活质量(QOL)会得到改善。对于老年人使用远程护理和远程医疗等基于ICT的护理服务,也有类似的假设。为了检验这些说法的证据,我们对2007年1月至2014年8月期间的学术文献和灰色文献进行了范围综述。采用基于ASCOT和WHOQOL模型的六个生活质量领域的框架分析方法,对相关文献进行演绎编码和分析。综述结果喜忧参半。老年人在主流和护理环境中使用ICT已被证明对生活质量的多个方面既有积极影响也有消极影响。严格评估老年人使用ICT对其生活质量影响的研究大多显示影响不大。一些定性研究报告了使用电子邮件或Skype等ICT与家人和朋友保持联系的老年人所获得的积极效果。总体而言,该综述揭示了老年人使用ICT对其生活质量影响方面的一些不一致之处,这表明需要就最佳研究方法和工具达成隐含共识,以充分描述当今数字时代老年人的经历。此外,现有证据并未考虑大量不使用ICT的老年人以及不使用ICT如何影响生活质量。