Madjar Shai, Sripada Chandra S
University of Michigan Medical SchoolAnn Arbor, MI, USA; Department of Philosophy, University of MichiganAnn Arbor, MI, USA.
Department of Philosophy, University of MichiganAnn Arbor, MI, USA; Department of Psychiatry, University of MichiganAnn Arbor, MI, USA.
Front Psychol. 2016 Feb 19;7:199. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00199. eCollection 2016.
Trichotillomania is a disorder characterized by recurrent urges to pull out one's hair, but the experiential characteristics of hair pulling urges are poorly understood. This study used a comparative approach to understand the subjective phenomenology of hair pulling: participants with trichotillomania symptoms were asked about their hair pulling urges as well as their urges to eat unhealthy foods. Participants who reported experiencing problematic unhealthy food urges were identified and asked to compare the phenomenological characteristics of their hair pulling and unhealthy food urges across a variety of dimensions. Results revealed significant differences for only some urge properties measured, and differences that existed were small to moderate in magnitude. Qualitative comparisons of the two urges revealed situational characteristics of hair pulling that could explain these small to moderate differences between the two urges. We conclude that hair pulling urges may be more comparable to ordinary urges such as unhealthy food urges than one might expect, but that hair pulling urges may nevertheless be rated as slightly more severe due to situational characteristics of these urges. This conception may improve clinician and lay understanding of the condition, assist with destigmatization efforts, and facilitate the development of treatment strategies.
拔毛癖是一种以反复出现拔自己头发的冲动为特征的疾病,但人们对拔毛冲动的体验特征了解甚少。本研究采用比较方法来理解拔毛的主观现象学:询问有拔毛癖症状的参与者关于他们拔毛的冲动以及吃不健康食物的冲动。识别出报告有问题的不健康食物冲动的参与者,并要求他们在多个维度上比较拔毛冲动和不健康食物冲动的现象学特征。结果显示,仅在所测量的一些冲动属性上存在显著差异,且存在的差异幅度较小到中等。对这两种冲动的定性比较揭示了拔毛的情境特征,这些特征可以解释这两种冲动之间的这些小到中等的差异。我们得出结论,拔毛冲动可能比人们预期的更类似于诸如不健康食物冲动等普通冲动,但由于这些冲动的情境特征,拔毛冲动可能仍被评为略为严重。这一概念可能会改善临床医生和外行对该病症的理解,有助于消除污名化的努力,并促进治疗策略的发展。