Toews J, el-Guebaly N
Department of Psychiatry, University of Calgary, Alberta.
Can J Psychiatry. 1989 Dec;34(9):928-33. doi: 10.1177/070674378903400915.
The efficacy of primary prevention of mental disorders has been debated over the years. The debate is complicated by ideology, semantic confusion, methodological difficulties and a paucity of good evaluative studies. This paper reviews newer concepts of primary prevention and mental health promotion, methodological issues, model programs, and inherent ethical concerns. Further evaluative studies and an increased contribution of psychiatrists to the primary prevention debate are recommended as necessary steps in further evolution of the field.
多年来,精神障碍一级预防的效果一直存在争议。意识形态、语义混淆、方法学难题以及高质量评估研究的匮乏使这场争论变得复杂。本文回顾了一级预防和心理健康促进的新概念、方法学问题、示范项目以及内在的伦理问题。作为该领域进一步发展的必要步骤,建议开展更多评估研究,并让精神科医生更多地参与到一级预防的争论中来。