Langereis Eveline J, den Os Matthijs M, Breen Catherine, Jones Simon A, Knaven Olga C, Mercer Jean, Miller Weston P, Kelly Paula M, Kennedy Jim, Ketterl Tyler G, O'Meara Anne, Orchard Paul J, Lund Troy C, van Rijn Rick R, Sakkers Ralph J, White Klane K, Wijburg Frits A
Department of Pediatric Metabolic Diseases, Emma Children's Hospital and Amsterdam Lysosome Center "Sphinx," Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Genetic Medicine, Manchester Academic Health Science Centre, Central Manchester University Hospitals, NHS Foundation Trust, St Mary's Hospital, Manchester, United Kingdom.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2016 Mar 2;98(5):386-95. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.O.00601.
Dysostosis multiplex contributes substantially to morbidity in patients with Hurler syndrome (mucopolysaccharidosis type I Hurler phenotype [MPS I-H]), even after successful hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). One of the hallmarks of dysostosis multiplex in MPS I-H is hip dysplasia, which often requires surgical intervention. We sought to describe in detail the course of hip dysplasia in this group of patients, as assessed by radiographic analysis, and to identify potential outcome predictors.
Longitudinal data were obtained from digitally scored pelvic radiographs of patients with MPS I-H using OrthoGon software for parameters including, but not limited to, the acetabular index, migration percentage, Smith ratio, and neck-shaft angle. Scoring was performed independently by two blinded observers. Additional information on genotype, enzyme replacement therapy pre-HSCT, donor chimerism, and enzyme activity post-HSCT were obtained. General trends and potential correlations were calculated with mixed-model statistics.
Fifty-two patients (192 radiographs) were included in this analysis. Intraobserver and interobserver variation analysis showed an intraclass correlation coefficient ranging from 0.78 to 1.00. Among the twenty-one patients with follow-up beyond the age of five years, the acetabular index was in the range of severe hip dysplasia in up to 86% of the patients. Severe coxa valga was seen in 91% of the patients. Lateral and superior femoral displacement were highly prevalent, with the migration percentage outside the reference range in up to 96% of the patients. Finally, anterior pelvic tilt increased with age (p = 0.001). No correlations were identified between clinical parameters and radiographic findings.
Our study shows that progressive acetabular dysplasia as well as coxa valga and hip displacement are highly prevalent and progressive over time in patients with MPS I-H, despite successful HSCT. These data may provide essential natural history determinations for the assessment of efficacy of new therapeutic strategies aimed at improving skeletal outcomes in patients with MPS I-H.
即使在成功进行造血干细胞移植(HSCT)后,多发性骨发育异常仍在很大程度上导致了Hurler综合征(I型粘多糖贮积症Hurler表型[MPS I-H])患者的发病。MPS I-H中多发性骨发育异常的一个标志是髋关节发育不良,这通常需要手术干预。我们试图通过影像学分析详细描述该组患者髋关节发育不良的病程,并确定潜在的预后预测因素。
使用OrthoGon软件从MPS I-H患者的数字化骨盆X光片中获取纵向数据,用于评估包括但不限于髋臼指数、移位百分比、史密斯比率和颈干角等参数。由两名不知情的观察者独立进行评分。还获取了关于基因型、HSCT前的酶替代治疗、供体嵌合率以及HSCT后的酶活性的额外信息。使用混合模型统计计算总体趋势和潜在相关性。
本分析纳入了52例患者(192张X光片)。观察者内和观察者间变异分析显示组内相关系数范围为0.78至1.00。在21例随访超过5岁的患者中,高达86%的患者髋臼指数处于严重髋关节发育不良范围内。91%的患者出现严重髋外翻。股骨外侧和上方移位非常普遍,高达96%的患者移位百分比超出参考范围。最后,骨盆前倾随年龄增加(p = 0.001)。未发现临床参数与影像学结果之间存在相关性。
我们的研究表明,尽管HSCT成功,但MPS I-H患者中进行性髋臼发育不良以及髋外翻和髋关节移位随着时间的推移非常普遍且呈进行性发展。这些数据可为评估旨在改善MPS I-H患者骨骼预后的新治疗策略的疗效提供重要的自然病程判定。