Saleh Nadia, Abdel Hay Rania, Hegazy Rehab, Hussein Marwa, Gomaa Dalia
Dermatology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University, Egypt.
J Telemed Telecare. 2017 Feb;23(2):233-238. doi: 10.1177/1357633X16633944. Epub 2016 Jul 9.
Introduction The paucity of studies evaluating teledermatology (TD) in developing countries was the impetus behind conducting this work. We aimed to evaluate the feasibility and reliability of TD in remote areas where medical facilities and consultant dermatologists are not available, through measurement of diagnostic concordance rates between face-to-face diagnosis and store-and-forward (SAF) TD diagnosis. Methods A total of 600 patients with dermatological ailments who attended Abshway Hospital were recruited into the study, examined by an on-site dermatology resident, and offered a diagnosis. The clinical images and patients' history were collected and transferred (through the Dropbox application) to two remote consultant dermatologists. The reliability of the three physicians' agreement rates was assessed. Results Diagnostic agreement rates between the face-to-face dermatologist and the two teledermatologists were 86.7% and 87% respectively. Of the cases, 97% had complete or partial agreement and 81.3% of cases showed complete agreement between the three physicians. The reliability of the three physicians' agreement rates was assessed statistically using Cohen's kappa coefficient (κ) and this showed a range of 0.46-0.52. Conclusion This study might aid in enhancing the utilization of this tool in our country, especially in remote areas with a lack of a proper dermatological service. The simplicity and low cost of the adopted technique might facilitate its use over large sectors. It opens the door for gaining the benefit of this technology in other aspects such as teaching and monitoring health care providers.
引言 在发展中国家,评估远程皮肤病学(TD)的研究较少,这是开展本研究的背后动力。我们旨在通过测量面对面诊断与存储转发(SAF)TD诊断之间的诊断一致性率,评估在缺乏医疗设施和皮肤科会诊医生的偏远地区TD的可行性和可靠性。
方法 总共招募了600名到阿布什韦医院就诊的皮肤病患者,由一名现场皮肤科住院医师进行检查并给出诊断。收集临床图像和患者病史,并(通过Dropbox应用程序)传输给两名远程皮肤科会诊医生。评估三位医生诊断一致率的可靠性。
结果 面对面皮肤科医生与两名远程皮肤科医生之间的诊断一致率分别为86.7%和87%。其中,97%的病例有完全或部分一致,81.3%的病例三位医生诊断完全一致。使用科恩kappa系数(κ)对三位医生诊断一致率的可靠性进行统计学评估,结果显示范围为0.46 - 0.52。
结论 本研究可能有助于在我国提高该工具的利用率,特别是在缺乏适当皮肤科服务的偏远地区。所采用技术的简单性和低成本可能便于在广大地区使用。它为在教学和监督医疗保健提供者等其他方面获得该技术的益处打开了大门。