Penn-Barwell Jowan G, Sargeant Ian D
Institute of Naval Medicine, Trauma and Orthopaedic Registrar Royal Navy, United Kingdom.
Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Injury. 2016 May;47(5):1067-71. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2016.02.004. Epub 2016 Feb 22.
Surgical treatment of high-energy gun-shot wounds (GSWs) to the extremities is challenging. Recent surgical doctrine states that wound tracts from high-energy GSWs should be laid open, however the experience from previous conflicts suggests that some of these injuries can be managed more conservatively. The aim of this study is to firstly characterise the GSW injuries sustained by UK forces, and secondly test the hypothesis that the likely severity of GSWs can be predicted by features of the wound.
The UK Military trauma registry was searched for cases injured by GSW in the five years between 01 January 2009 and 31 December 2013: only UK personnel were included. Clinical notes and radiographs were then reviewed. Features associated with energy transfer in extremity wounds in survivors were further examined with number of wound debridements used as a surrogate marker of wound severity.
There were 450 cases who met the inclusion criteria. 96 (21%) were fatally injured, with 354 (79%) surviving their injuries. Casualties in the fatality group had a median New Injury Severity Score (NISS) of 75 (IQR 75-75), while the median NISS of the survivors was 12 (IQR 4-48) with 10 survivors having a NISS of 75. In survivors the limbs were most commonly injured (56%). 'Through and through' wounds, where the bullet passes intact through the body, were strongly associated with less requirement for debridement (p<0.0001). When a bullet fragmented there was a significant association with a requirement for a greater number of wound debridements (p=0.0002), as there was if a bullet fractured a bone (p=0.0006).
More complex wounds, as indicated by the requirement for repeated debridements, are associated with injuries where the bullet does not pass straight through the body, or where a bone is fractured. Gunshot wounds should be assessed according to the likely energy transferred, extremity wounds without features of high energy transfer do not require extensive exploration.
对四肢的高能枪伤进行手术治疗具有挑战性。近期的外科原则指出,高能枪伤的伤口通道应敞开,但以往冲突的经验表明,其中一些损伤可以采用更保守的处理方法。本研究的目的,一是描述英国军队所遭受的枪伤情况,二是检验能否根据伤口特征预测枪伤可能的严重程度这一假设。
在英国军事创伤登记处检索2009年1月1日至2013年12月31日这五年间受枪伤的病例:仅纳入英国人员。然后查阅临床记录和X光片。以伤口清创次数作为伤口严重程度的替代指标,进一步研究幸存者四肢伤口中与能量传递相关的特征。
有450例符合纳入标准。96例(21%)因伤死亡,354例(79%)受伤后存活。死亡组伤员的新损伤严重程度评分(NISS)中位数为75(四分位间距75 - 75),而幸存者的NISS中位数为12(四分位间距4 - 48),有10名幸存者的NISS为75。在幸存者中,四肢受伤最为常见(56%)。子弹完整穿过身体的“贯通伤”与较少的清创需求密切相关(p<0.0001)。当子弹碎裂时,与更多次数的伤口清创需求显著相关(p = 0.0002),子弹导致骨折时也是如此(p = 0.0006)。
如反复清创需求所示,更复杂的伤口与子弹未直接穿过身体或导致骨折的损伤相关。应根据可能传递的能量评估枪伤,无高能传递特征的四肢伤口无需广泛探查。