Weiser Thomas G, Haynes Alex B, Molina George, Lipsitz Stuart R, Esquivel Micaela M, Uribe-Leitz Tarsicio, Fu Rui, Azad Tej, Chao Tiffany E, Berry William R, Gawande Atul A
Stanford University Medical Center, Department of Surgery, 300 Pasteur Drive (S067), Stanford, CA 94305, United States of America (USA).
Ariadne Labs, Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, USA .
Bull World Health Organ. 2016 Mar 1;94(3):201-209F. doi: 10.2471/BLT.15.159293.
To estimate global surgical volume in 2012 and compare it with estimates from 2004.
For the 194 Member States of the World Health Organization, we searched PubMed for studies and contacted key informants for reports on surgical volumes between 2005 and 2012. We obtained data on population and total health expenditure per capita for 2012 and categorized Member States as very-low, low, middle and high expenditure. Data on caesarean delivery were obtained from validated statistical reports. For Member States without recorded surgical data, we estimated volumes by multiple imputation using data on total health expenditure. We estimated caesarean deliveries as a proportion of all surgery.
We identified 66 Member States reporting surgical data. We estimated that 312.9 million operations (95% confidence interval, CI: 266.2-359.5) took place in 2012, an increase from the 2004 estimate of 226.4 million operations. Only 6.3% (95% CI: 1.7-22.9) and 23.1% (95% CI: 14.8-36.7) of operations took place in very-low- and low-expenditure Member States representing 36.8% (2573 million people) and 34.2% (2393 million people) of the global population of 7001 million people, respectively. Caesarean deliveries comprised 29.6% (5.8/19.6 million operations; 95% CI: 9.7-91.7) of the total surgical volume in very-low-expenditure Member States, but only 2.7% (5.1/187.0 million operations; 95% CI: 2.2-3.4) in high-expenditure Member States.
Surgical volume is large and growing, with caesarean delivery comprising nearly a third of operations in most resource-poor settings. Nonetheless, there remains disparity in the provision of surgical services globally.
估算2012年全球外科手术量,并与2004年的估算值进行比较。
针对世界卫生组织的194个成员国,我们在PubMed上搜索研究,并联系关键信息提供者以获取2005年至2012年期间外科手术量的报告。我们获取了2012年各国的人口数据和人均卫生总支出数据,并将成员国分为极低、低、中、高支出类别。剖宫产数据来自经过验证的统计报告。对于没有记录外科手术数据的成员国,我们使用卫生总支出数据通过多重填补法估算手术量。我们将剖宫产手术量估算为所有手术量的一部分。
我们确定了66个报告外科手术数据的成员国。我们估计2012年共进行了3.129亿例手术(95%置信区间,CI:2.662 - 3.595亿例),较2004年估计的2.264亿例有所增加。在代表全球70.01亿人口中36.8%(25.73亿人)和34.2%(23.93亿人)的极低和低支出成员国中,分别仅进行了6.3%(95%CI:1.7 - 22.9%)和23.1%(95%CI:14.8 - 36.7%)的手术。在极低支出成员国中,剖宫产手术占外科手术总量的29.6%(580万/1960万例手术;95%CI:9.7 - 91.7%),而在高支出成员国中仅占2.7%(510万/1.87亿例手术;95%CI:2.2 - 3.4%)。
外科手术量庞大且在增长,在大多数资源匮乏地区,剖宫产手术占手术总量的近三分之一。尽管如此,全球外科服务的提供仍存在差异。