Navas Patricia, Rodríguez-Santos Lucía, Bauzano-Poley Enrique, Lara José Pablo, Barbancho Miguel Ángel
Hospital Regional Universitario de Malaga. Hospital Materno Infantil, Malaga, Espana.
Andalucia Tech. Centro de Investigaciones Medico-Sanitarias (CIMES). Universidad de Malaga, Malaga, Espana.
Rev Neurol. 2016 Apr 1;62(7):289-95.
Although sleep deprivation has been used for years in electroencephalography (EEG) as a method for activating interictal epileptiform discharges (IED) in patients with a strong suspicion of epilepsy, its sensitivity and specificity are still under discussion.
We conducted a descriptive retrospective study of paediatric patients who were referred to a neurophysiology clinic for epilepsy assessment. The results of the sleep-deprived EEG (SD-EEG) were compared with those of the wakefulness EEG (W-EEG) carried out in each patient in order to describe the performance of each method as a mechanism for activating IED.
A total of 500 patients were analysed (830 SD-EEG and 1018 W-EEG). IED were detected in 44% of the W-EEG. SD-EEG increased the capacity of the test to detect IED by 35%. IED (not detected in the W-EEG) were detected in 25.1% of the SD-EEG in which spontaneous sleep was achieved. In the group of focal epilepsies, it was found that W-EEG detected IED in 60.1% versus the 79.12% displayed with SD-EEG. In generalised epilepsies this difference was more marked (27.2% and 77.2%, respectively). In patients in whom no IED were detected following an SD-EEG (23.7%) and the clinical suspicion of epilepsy was still high, nocturnal polysomnography was performed and interictal epileptiform activity was observed in 13.6%.
SD-EEG increases the chances of recording IED by 35% with respect to W-EEG. Sleep deprivation is a method for activating epileptiform paroxysms, regardless of whether the EEG is performed while sleeping or not, although this effect is more pronounced in patients who do manage to sleep.
尽管睡眠剥夺多年来一直被用于脑电图(EEG)检查,作为一种激活高度怀疑患有癫痫患者的发作间期癫痫样放电(IED)的方法,但其敏感性和特异性仍存在争议。
我们对转诊至神经生理学诊所进行癫痫评估的儿科患者进行了一项描述性回顾性研究。将每位患者的睡眠剥夺脑电图(SD-EEG)结果与清醒脑电图(W-EEG)结果进行比较,以描述每种方法作为激活IED机制的性能。
共分析了500例患者(830次SD-EEG和1018次W-EEG)。在44%的W-EEG中检测到IED。SD-EEG使检测IED的测试能力提高了35%。在实现自然睡眠的SD-EEG中,25.1%检测到了W-EEG中未检测到的IED。在局灶性癫痫组中,发现W-EEG检测到IED的比例为60.1%,而SD-EEG为79.12%。在全身性癫痫中,这种差异更为明显(分别为27.2%和77.2%)。在SD-EEG后未检测到IED的患者(23.7%)中,且临床癫痫怀疑度仍较高时,进行了夜间多导睡眠图检查,其中13.6%观察到发作间期癫痫样活动。
与W-EEG相比,SD-EEG记录到IED的几率提高了35%。睡眠剥夺是一种激活癫痫样发作的方法,无论脑电图检查是在睡眠时还是清醒时进行,尽管这种效果在成功入睡的患者中更为明显。