Calpin Pádraig, Imran Ather, Harmon Dominic
Anesthesia, Intensive Care and Pain Medicine, University Hospital Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
Pain Pract. 2017 Mar;17(3):305-311. doi: 10.1111/papr.12428. Epub 2016 Mar 15.
The patient-physician encounter forms the cornerstone of every health service. However, optimal medical outcomes are often confounded by inadequate patient-physician communication. Chronic pain is estimated to affect over 25% of the population. Its effects are multifaceted with patients at increased risk of experiencing emotional and functional disturbances. Therefore, it is crucial to address all components of the patient's pain experience, including beliefs and expectations. It is our understanding that no other study to date has evaluated the expectations of physicians and compared them to those of patients for pain clinic visits. We sought to describe and compare expectations of chronic pain patients and their physicians during a clinic consultation.
We performed a retrospective review on patients attending the pain clinic for the first time who were enrolled and completed a questionnaire asking their expectations for their clinic visit as well as outcomes that would satisfy and disappoint them. Pain physicians were also included. We compared physicians' to patients' responses and evaluated relationships between patient responses and age, gender, pain location, Pain Self-Efficacy, Pain Catastrophizing Scale, and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale.
One hundred chronic pain patients and 10 pain physicians were surveyed. Patients' clinical expectations for visits focused primarily on some pain relief (34%), education on the cause of pain (24%), and a definitive diagnosis (18%). Physician's expectations included formulation and communication of a management plan (70%), patient assessment for cause of pain (50%), and the education of patients on the cause of pain (40%) as important aims. Pain relief would satisfy the majority of patients (74%) and physicians (70%). No improvement would cause greatest dissatisfaction for patients (52%), but causing more harm would be disappointing to physicians (50%). Gender, age, pain location, and sleep quality all significantly influenced patients' expectations and affective pain comorbidities.
We found some agreement and some discordance of clinical expectations between pain patients and physicians. Patient factors may also impact on expectations and comorbidities. Findings from this study will help doctors consider patients' expectations in planning pain clinic visits, improve patient-doctor communication and pain management, and may lead to further hypothesis-driven studies.
医患会面是每项医疗服务的基石。然而,最佳医疗结果常常因医患沟通不足而受到影响。据估计,慢性疼痛影响着超过25%的人口。其影响是多方面的,患者出现情绪和功能障碍的风险增加。因此,解决患者疼痛体验的所有方面,包括信念和期望,至关重要。据我们了解,迄今为止尚无其他研究评估医生的期望并将其与疼痛门诊患者的期望进行比较。我们试图描述和比较慢性疼痛患者及其医生在门诊咨询期间的期望。
我们对首次到疼痛门诊就诊并登记的患者进行了回顾性研究,这些患者完成了一份问卷,询问他们对门诊就诊的期望以及会令他们满意和失望的结果。疼痛科医生也参与其中。我们比较了医生和患者的回答,并评估了患者回答与年龄、性别、疼痛部位、疼痛自我效能感、疼痛灾难化量表以及医院焦虑抑郁量表之间的关系。
共调查了100名慢性疼痛患者和10名疼痛科医生。患者对就诊的临床期望主要集中在一定程度的疼痛缓解(34%)、疼痛原因的教育(24%)以及明确诊断(18%)。医生的期望包括制定和传达管理计划(70%)、对患者疼痛原因进行评估(50%)以及对患者进行疼痛原因的教育(40%),这些被视为重要目标。疼痛缓解会使大多数患者(74%)和医生(70%)感到满意。没有改善会导致大多数患者最大程度的不满(52%),但对医生而言,造成更多伤害会令他们失望(50%)。性别、年龄、疼痛部位和睡眠质量均显著影响患者的期望和情感性疼痛共病。
我们发现疼痛患者和医生在临床期望方面存在一些一致和不一致之处。患者因素也可能影响期望和共病情况。本研究结果将有助于医生在规划疼痛门诊就诊时考虑患者的期望,改善医患沟通和疼痛管理,并可能引发进一步的假设驱动研究。