Cheriachan Deepak, Hughes Adrian M, du Moulin William S M, Williams Christopher, Molnar Robert
*Department of Surgery, Westmead Hospital, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia; and †Sydney Orthopaedic Trauma and Reconstructive Surgery, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
J Orthop Trauma. 2016 Jul;30(7):e230-5. doi: 10.1097/BOT.0000000000000578.
To evaluate the ionizing radiation dose received by the eyes of orthopaedic surgeons during various orthopaedic procedures. Secondary objective was to compare the ionizing radiation dose received between differing experience level.
Prospective comparative study between January 2013 and May 2014.
Westmead Hospital, a Level 1 Trauma Centre for Greater Western Sydney.
A total of 26 surgeons volunteered to participate within the study.
Experience level, procedure performed, fluoroscopy time, dose area product, total air kerma, and eye dose received was recorded. Participants were evaluated on procedure and experience level.
Radiation dose received at eye level by the primary surgeon during an orthopaedic procedure.
Data from a total of 131 cases was recorded and included for analysis. The mean radiation dose detected at the eye level of the primary surgeon was 0.02 mSv (SD = 0.05 mSv) per procedure. Radiation at eye level was only detected in 31 of the 131 cases. The highest registered dose for a single procedure was 0.31 mSv. Femoral nails and pelvic fixation procedures had a significantly higher mean dose received than other procedure groups (0.04 mSv (SD = 0.07 mSv) and 0.04 mSv (SD = 0.06 mSv), respectively). Comparing the eye doses received by orthopaedic consultants and trainees, there was no significant difference between the 2 groups.
The risk of harmful levels of radiation exposure at eye level to orthopaedic surgeons is low. This risk is greatest during insertion of femoral intramedullary nails and pelvic fixation, and it is recommended that in these situations, surgeons take all reasonable precautions to minimize radiation dose. The orthopaedic trainees in this study were not subjected to higher doses of radiation than their consultant trainers. On the basis of these results, most of the orthopaedic surgeons remain well below the yearly radiation dose of 20 mSv as recommended by the International Commission on Radiological Protection.
评估骨科医生在各种骨科手术过程中眼睛所接受的电离辐射剂量。次要目的是比较不同经验水平的医生所接受的电离辐射剂量。
2013年1月至2014年5月的前瞻性对照研究。
西梅德医院,大悉尼地区的一级创伤中心。
共有26名外科医生自愿参与本研究。
记录经验水平、实施的手术、透视时间、剂量面积乘积、总空气比释动能以及眼睛所接受的剂量。根据手术和经验水平对参与者进行评估。
主刀医生在骨科手术过程中眼睛水平所接受的辐射剂量。
共记录并纳入131例病例的数据进行分析。主刀医生眼睛水平检测到的平均辐射剂量为每次手术0.02毫希沃特(标准差 = 0.05毫希沃特)。在131例病例中,仅31例检测到眼睛水平的辐射。单次手术记录到的最高剂量为0.31毫希沃特。股骨钉和骨盆固定手术的平均接受剂量显著高于其他手术组(分别为0.04毫希沃特(标准差 = 0.07毫希沃特)和0.04毫希沃特(标准差 = 0.06毫希沃特))。比较骨科顾问医生和实习医生眼睛所接受的剂量,两组之间无显著差异。
骨科医生眼睛水平受到有害辐射暴露的风险较低。在插入股骨髓内钉和骨盆固定过程中这种风险最大,建议在这些情况下,外科医生采取一切合理预防措施以尽量减少辐射剂量。本研究中的骨科实习医生所接受的辐射剂量并不高于他们的带教顾问医生。基于这些结果,大多数骨科医生的辐射剂量仍远低于国际放射防护委员会建议的每年20毫希沃特的剂量。