Joffe Megan, MacLeod Sheona, Kedziora Marta, Main Paul
a Edgecumbe Health , Bristol , UK.
b East Midlands Healthcare Workforce Deanery , Leicester , UK.
Educ Prim Care. 2016 May;27(3):205-13. doi: 10.1080/14739879.2016.1147135. Epub 2016 Apr 8.
This study looked at differences between established GP trainers and current GP trainees in relation to personality traits. Personality differences are particularly important for training in the UK context where the attributes of successful GPs may be evolving as the context changes, and where there is a unique one-to-one relationship between trainer and trainee. GP trainers and trainees attending educational events were invited to participate in this study by completing the NEO-PI-R, a personality measure. Correlation and multiple regression analysis demonstrated differences between these groups; some in line with expected differences relating to age and gender. Others, such as lower reported levels of emotional resilience, may be particular to this trainee population. Overall the gender differences are significant given the trend towards the feminisation of the medical profession. Generational differences may also explain some behaviour and attitudinal differences which can aid trainers' understanding of training issues. The findings have important implications for training, particularly in relation to the development of emotional resilience for GP trainees, and for recruitment. Further research correlating educational outcomes and perceived satisfaction with a GP career and GP training would indicate if trainer/trainee personality differences have a direct bearing on educational outcomes and future practice.
本研究探讨了执业全科医生培训师与当前全科医生学员在人格特质方面的差异。在英国的背景下,人格差异对于培训尤为重要,因为随着环境的变化,成功的全科医生的特质可能也在演变,而且培训师与学员之间存在独特的一对一关系。参加教育活动的全科医生培训师和学员被邀请通过完成NEO-PI-R(一种人格测量工具)来参与本研究。相关性和多元回归分析表明了这些群体之间的差异;有些差异与年龄和性别预期差异相符。其他差异,比如较低的情绪恢复力报告水平,可能是该学员群体所特有的。鉴于医学专业女性化的趋势,总体上性别差异很显著。代际差异也可能解释一些行为和态度上的差异,这有助于培训师理解培训问题。这些发现对培训具有重要意义,特别是对于全科医生学员情绪恢复力的培养以及招聘方面。将教育成果与对全科医生职业和全科医生培训的感知满意度相关联的进一步研究,将表明培训师/学员的人格差异是否对教育成果和未来实践有直接影响。