Hwang Jae Joon, Park Hyok, Jeong Ho-Gul, Han Sang-Sun
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, College of Dentistry, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea.
PLoS One. 2016 Apr 19;11(4):e0153884. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0153884. eCollection 2016.
A patient's position changes in every CBCT scan despite patient alignment protocols. However, there have been studies to determine image quality differences when an object is located at the center of the field of view (FOV). To evaluate changes in the image quality of the CBCT scan according to different object positions, the image quality indexes of the Alphard 3030 (Alphard Roentgen Ind., Ltd., Kyoto, Japan) and the Rayscan Symphony (RAY Ind., Ltd., Suwon, Korea) were measured using the Quart DVT_AP phantom at the center of the FOV and 6 peripheral positions under four types of exposure conditions. Anterior, posterior, right, left, upper, and lower positions 1 cm offset from the center of the FOV were used for the peripheral positions. We evaluated and compared the voxel size, homogeneity, contrast to noise ratio (CNR), and the 10% point of the modulation transfer function (MTF10%) of the center and periphery. Because the voxel size, which is determined by the Nyquist frequency, was within tolerance, other image quality indexes were not influenced by the voxel size. For the CNR, homogeneity, and MTF10%, there were peripheral positions which showed considerable differences with statistical significance. The average difference between the center and periphery was up to 31.27% (CNR), 70.49% (homogeneity), and 13.64% (MTF10%). Homogeneity was under tolerance at some of the peripheral locations. Because the CNR, homogeneity, and MTF10% were significantly affected by positional changes of the phantom, an object's position can influence the interpretation of follow up CBCT images. Therefore, efforts to locate the object in the same position are important.
尽管有患者对齐方案,但在每次锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)中患者的位置都会发生变化。然而,已有研究确定当物体位于视野(FOV)中心时的图像质量差异。为了评估根据不同物体位置CBCT扫描图像质量的变化,使用Quart DVT_AP体模在FOV中心和四个曝光条件下的六个外周位置测量了Alphard 3030(日本京都Alphard Roentgen Ind., Ltd.)和Rayscan Symphony(韩国水原RAY Ind., Ltd.)的图像质量指标。外周位置采用距FOV中心偏移1 cm的前、后、右、左、上和下位置。我们评估并比较了中心和外周的体素大小、均匀性、对比度噪声比(CNR)以及调制传递函数的10%点(MTF10%)。由于由奈奎斯特频率决定的体素大小在公差范围内,其他图像质量指标不受体素大小的影响。对于CNR、均匀性和MTF10%,存在具有统计学意义的显著差异的外周位置。中心和外周之间的平均差异高达31.27%(CNR)、70.49%(均匀性)和13.64%(MTF10%)。在一些外周位置均匀性超出公差范围。由于CNR、均匀性和MTF10%受体模位置变化的显著影响,物体的位置会影响后续CBCT图像的解读。因此,将物体定位在相同位置的努力很重要。