Cowpland Christine A, Cleese Amy L, Whiteley Mark S
1 The Whiteley Clinic, Stirling House, UK.
2 Faculty of Health and Biomedical Sciences, University of Surrey, UK.
Phlebology. 2017 Jun;32(5):299-306. doi: 10.1177/0268355516648067. Epub 2016 May 12.
Objectives The objective is to identify the factors that affect the optimal linear endovenous energy density (LEED) to ablate incompetent truncal veins. Methods We performed a literature review of clinical studies, which reported truncal vein ablation rates and LEED. A PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis) flow diagram documents the search strategy. We analysed 13 clinical papers which fulfilled the criteria to be able to compare results of great saphenous vein occlusion as defined by venous duplex ultrasound, with the LEED used in the treatment. Results Evidence suggests that the optimal LEED for endovenous laser ablation of the great saphenous vein is >80 J/cm and <100 J/cm in terms of optimal closure rates with minimal side-effects and complications. Longer wavelengths targeting water might have a lower optimal LEED. A LEED <60 J/cm has reduced efficacy regardless of wavelength. The optimal LEED may vary with vein diameter and may be reduced by using specially shaped fibre tips. Laser delivery technique and type as well as the duration time of energy delivery appear to play a role in determining LEED. Conclusion The optimal LEED to ablate an incompetent great saphenous vein appears to be >80 J/cm and <95 J/cm based on current evidence for shorter wavelength lasers. There is evidence that longer wavelength lasers may be effective at LEEDs of <85 J/cm.
目的 目的是确定影响消融功能不全的主干静脉的最佳线性静脉内能量密度(LEED)的因素。方法 我们对报告主干静脉消融率和LEED的临床研究进行了文献综述。一份PRISMA(系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目)流程图记录了检索策略。我们分析了13篇符合标准的临床论文,以便能够将静脉双重超声定义的大隐静脉闭塞结果与治疗中使用的LEED进行比较。结果 证据表明,就具有最小副作用和并发症的最佳闭合率而言,大隐静脉腔内激光消融的最佳LEED为>80 J/cm且<100 J/cm。针对水的较长波长可能具有较低的最佳LEED。无论波长如何,LEED<60 J/cm会降低疗效。最佳LEED可能随静脉直径而变化,并且使用特殊形状的光纤尖端可能会降低最佳LEED。激光输送技术和类型以及能量输送的持续时间似乎在确定LEED中起作用。结论 根据目前关于较短波长激光的证据,消融功能不全的大隐静脉的最佳LEED似乎为>80 J/cm且<95 J/cm。有证据表明,较长波长的激光在<85 J/cm的LEED下可能有效。