Younes A, Delay F, Fajraoui N, Fahs M, Mara T A
LHyGES, Université de Strasbourg/EOST, CNRS, 1 rue Blessig, 67084 Strasbourg, France; IRD UMR LISAH, F-92761 Montpellier, France.
LHyGES, Université de Strasbourg/EOST, CNRS, 1 rue Blessig, 67084 Strasbourg, France.
J Contam Hydrol. 2016 Aug;191:1-18. doi: 10.1016/j.jconhyd.2016.04.007. Epub 2016 May 3.
The concept of dual flowing continuum is a promising approach for modeling solute transport in porous media that includes biofilm phases. The highly dispersed transit time distributions often generated by these media are taken into consideration by simply stipulating that advection-dispersion transport occurs through both the porous and the biofilm phases. Both phases are coupled but assigned with contrasting hydrodynamic properties. However, the dual flowing continuum suffers from intrinsic equifinality in the sense that the outlet solute concentration can be the result of several parameter sets of the two flowing phases. To assess the applicability of the dual flowing continuum, we investigate how the model behaves with respect to its parameters. For the purpose of this study, a Global Sensitivity Analysis (GSA) and a Statistical Calibration (SC) of model parameters are performed for two transport scenarios that differ by the strength of interaction between the flowing phases. The GSA is shown to be a valuable tool to understand how the complex system behaves. The results indicate that the rate of mass transfer between the two phases is a key parameter of the model behavior and influences the identifiability of the other parameters. For weak mass exchanges, the output concentration is mainly controlled by the velocity in the porous medium and by the porosity of both flowing phases. In the case of large mass exchanges, the kinetics of this exchange also controls the output concentration. The SC results show that transport with large mass exchange between the flowing phases is more likely affected by equifinality than transport with weak exchange. The SC also indicates that weakly sensitive parameters, such as the dispersion in each phase, can be accurately identified. Removing them from calibration procedures is not recommended because it might result in biased estimations of the highly sensitive parameters.
双流连续介质概念是一种很有前景的方法,用于对包含生物膜相的多孔介质中的溶质输运进行建模。这些介质通常会产生高度分散的渡越时间分布,通过简单规定平流 - 弥散输运在多孔相和生物膜相中都发生来予以考虑。两相相互耦合,但赋予了截然不同的流体动力学特性。然而,双流连续介质存在内在的等效最终性问题,即出口溶质浓度可能是两个流动相的几组参数的结果。为了评估双流连续介质的适用性,我们研究该模型在其参数方面的表现。出于本研究的目的,针对两个因流动相之间相互作用强度不同而有所差异的输运场景,对模型参数进行了全局敏感性分析(GSA)和统计校准(SC)。结果表明,GSA是理解复杂系统行为的一个有价值的工具。结果表明,两相之间的传质速率是模型行为的一个关键参数,并影响其他参数的可识别性。对于弱质量交换,输出浓度主要由多孔介质中的流速以及两个流动相的孔隙率控制。在大量质量交换的情况下,这种交换的动力学也控制输出浓度。SC结果表明,与弱交换的输运相比,流动相之间大量质量交换的输运更可能受到等效最终性的影响。SC还表明,诸如各相中的弥散等弱敏感参数可以被准确识别。不建议在校准过程中去除它们,因为这可能会导致对高敏感参数的有偏估计。