Barras Caroline, Kerzel Dirk
Faculté de Psychologie et des Sciences de l'Education, Université de Genève Geneva, Switzerland.
Front Psychol. 2016 May 2;7:630. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00630. eCollection 2016.
It has been claimed that stimuli sharing the color of the nogo-target are suppressed because of the strong incentive to not process the nogo-target, but we failed to replicate this finding. Participants searched for a color singleton in the target display and indicated its shape when it was in the go color. If the color singleton in the target display was in the nogo color, they had to withhold the response. The target display was preceded by a cue display that also contained a color singleton (the cue). The cue was either in the color of the go or nogo target, or it was in an unrelated, neutral color. With cues in the go color, reaction times were shorter when the cue appeared at the same location as the target compared to when it appeared at a different location. Also, electrophysiological recordings showed that an index of attentional selection, the N2pc, was elicited by go cues. Surprisingly, we failed to replicate cueing costs for cues in the nogo color that were originally reported by Anderson and Folk (2012). Consistently, we also failed to find an electrophysiological index of attentional suppression (the PD) for cues in the nogo color. Further, fronto-central event-related potentials to the cue display showed the same negativity for nogo and neutral stimuli relative to go stimuli, which is at odds with response inhibition and conflict monitoring accounts of the Nogo-N2. Thus, the modified cueing paradigm employed here provides little evidence that features associated with nogo-targets are suppressed at the level of attention or response selection. Rather, nogo-stimuli are efficiently ignored and attention is focused on features that require a response.
有人认为,由于强烈的不处理非目标刺激的动机,与非目标刺激颜色相同的刺激会受到抑制,但我们未能重复这一发现。参与者在目标显示中搜索颜色单一的刺激,并在其为执行刺激颜色时指出其形状。如果目标显示中的颜色单一刺激为非执行刺激颜色,他们必须抑制反应。目标显示之前有一个提示显示,其中也包含一个颜色单一的刺激(提示)。提示要么是执行目标或非执行目标的颜色,要么是无关的中性颜色。当提示为执行刺激颜色时,与出现在不同位置相比,提示出现在与目标相同位置时的反应时间更短。此外,电生理记录表明,执行提示会引发注意力选择指标N2pc。令人惊讶的是,我们未能重复Anderson和Folk(2012)最初报道的非执行刺激颜色提示的提示成本。同样,我们也未能找到非执行刺激颜色提示的注意力抑制电生理指标(PD)。此外,对提示显示的额中央事件相关电位显示,相对于执行刺激,非执行刺激和中性刺激的负性相同,这与非执行刺激N2的反应抑制和冲突监测解释不一致。因此,这里采用的改进提示范式几乎没有提供证据表明与非目标刺激相关的特征在注意力或反应选择水平上受到抑制。相反,非执行刺激被有效地忽略,注意力集中在需要反应的特征上。