Nyman Jonas, Pundyke Orla Sheehan, Day Graeme M
School of Chemistry, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2016 Jun 21;18(23):15828-37. doi: 10.1039/c6cp02261h. Epub 2016 May 27.
We present an assessment of the performance of several force fields for modelling intermolecular interactions in organic molecular crystals using the X23 benchmark set. The performance of the force fields is compared to several popular dispersion corrected density functional methods. In addition, we present our implementation of lattice vibrational free energy calculations in the quasi-harmonic approximation, using several methods to account for phonon dispersion. This allows us to also benchmark the force fields' reproduction of finite temperature crystal structures. The results demonstrate that anisotropic atom-atom multipole-based force fields can be as accurate as several popular DFT-D methods, but have errors 2-3 times larger than the current best DFT-D methods. The largest error in the examined force fields is a systematic underestimation of the (absolute) lattice energy.
我们使用X23基准集对几种用于模拟有机分子晶体中分子间相互作用的力场性能进行了评估。将这些力场的性能与几种常用的色散校正密度泛函方法进行了比较。此外,我们还介绍了在准谐近似下晶格振动自由能计算的实现方法,使用了几种方法来考虑声子色散。这使我们能够对标力场对有限温度晶体结构的再现性。结果表明,基于各向异性原子 - 原子多极的力场可以与几种常用的DFT - D方法一样准确,但误差比当前最佳的DFT - D方法大2至3倍。在所研究的力场中,最大的误差是对(绝对)晶格能的系统性低估。