Ruffini Nuria, D'Alessandro Giandomenico, Cardinali Lucia, Frondaroli Franco, Cerritelli Francesco
Clinical-based Human Research Department (C.O.ME. Collaboration), Pescara, Italy; Accademia Italiana Osteopatia Tradizionale (AIOT), Pescara, Italy.
Gynecology and Obstetrics department, University of Chieti, Chieti, Italy.
Complement Ther Med. 2016 Jun;26:72-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2016.03.005. Epub 2016 Mar 7.
The aim of the review was to evaluate the effects of the osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) on women with gynaecological and obstetric disorders.
An extensive search from inception to April 2014 was conducted on MEDLINE, Embase, the Cochrane library using MeSH and free terms. Clinical studies investigating the effect of OMT in gynaecologic and obstetric conditions were included as well as unpublished works. Reviews and personal contributions were excluded. Studies were screened for population, outcome, results and adverse effects by two independent reviewers using an ad-hoc data extraction form. The high heterogeneity of the studies led to a narrative review.
24 studies were included (total sample=1840), addressing back pain and low back functioning in pregnancy, pain and drug use during labor and delivery, infertility and subfertility, dysmenorrhea, symptoms of (peri)menopause and pelvic pain. Overall, OMT can be considered effective on pregnancy related back pain but uncertain in all other gynaecological and obstetrical conditions. Only three studies (12.5%) mentioned adverse events after OMT.
Although positive effects were found, the heterogeneity of study designs, the low number of studies and the high risk of bias of included trials prevented any indication on the effect of osteopathic care. Further investigation with more pragmatic methodology, better and detailed description of interventions and systematic reporting of adverse events are recommended in order to obtain solid and generalizable results.
本综述旨在评估整骨手法治疗(OMT)对患有妇产科疾病女性的影响。
从创刊至2014年4月,使用医学主题词(MeSH)和自由词在MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane图书馆进行了广泛检索。纳入了调查OMT在妇产科疾病中作用的临床研究以及未发表的作品。排除综述和个人投稿。两名独立评审员使用专门的数据提取表对研究的人群、结局、结果和不良反应进行筛选。研究的高度异质性导致进行叙述性综述。
纳入24项研究(总样本量=1840),涉及妊娠期间的背痛和腰椎功能、分娩期间的疼痛和药物使用、不孕和亚生育、痛经、(围)绝经期症状和盆腔疼痛。总体而言,OMT可被认为对与妊娠相关的背痛有效,但在所有其他妇产科疾病中效果不确定。只有三项研究(12.5%)提及OMT后的不良事件。
尽管发现了积极效果,但研究设计的异质性、研究数量少以及纳入试验的高偏倚风险阻碍了对整骨疗法效果得出任何结论。建议采用更实用的方法进行进一步研究,更好且详细地描述干预措施,并系统报告不良事件,以获得可靠且可推广的结果。