Liu Richard T, Cheek Shayna M, Nestor Bridget A
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Alpert Medical School of Brown University, United States.
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Alpert Medical School of Brown University, United States.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2016 Jul;47:1-14. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2016.05.005. Epub 2016 May 31.
Recent years have seen a considerable growth of interest in the study of life stress and non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI). The current article presents a systematic review of the empirical literature on this association. In addition to providing a comprehensive meta-analysis, the current article includes a qualitative review of the findings for which there were too few cases (i.e., <3) for reliable approximations of effect sizes. Across the studies included in the meta-analysis, a significant but modest relation between life stress and NSSI was found (pooled OR=1.81 [95% CI=1.49-2.21]). After an adjustment was made for publication bias, the estimated effect size was smaller but still significant (pooled OR=1.33 [95% CI=1.08-1.63]). This relation was moderated by sample type, NSSI measure type, and length of period covered by the NSSI measure. The empirical literature is characterized by several methodological limitations, particularly the frequent use of cross-sectional analyses involving temporal overlap between assessments of life stress and NSSI, leaving unclear the precise nature of the relation between these two phenomena (e.g., whether life stress may be a cause, concomitant, or consequence of NSSI). Theoretically informed research utilizing multi-wave designs, assessing life stress and NSSI over relatively brief intervals, and featuring interview-based assessments of these constructs holds promise for advancing our understanding of their relation. The current review concludes with a theoretical elaboration of the association between NSSI and life stress, with the aim of providing a conceptual framework to guide future study in this area.
近年来,人们对生活压力与非自杀性自伤(NSSI)的研究兴趣显著增长。本文对有关这种关联的实证文献进行了系统综述。除了提供全面的荟萃分析外,本文还对那些因案例过少(即<3)而无法可靠估算效应大小的研究结果进行了定性综述。在纳入荟萃分析的各项研究中,发现生活压力与NSSI之间存在显著但适度的关联(合并比值比=1.81 [95%置信区间=1.49 - 2.21])。在对发表偏倚进行校正后,估计的效应大小较小但仍具有显著性(合并比值比=1.33 [95%置信区间=1.08 - 1.63])。这种关联受到样本类型、NSSI测量类型以及NSSI测量所涵盖时间段长度的调节。实证文献存在若干方法学局限性,尤其是频繁使用横断面分析,其中生活压力评估与NSSI评估之间存在时间重叠,这使得这两种现象之间关系的精确性质尚不清楚(例如,生活压力是NSSI的原因、伴随因素还是结果)。利用多波设计、在相对较短的时间间隔内评估生活压力和NSSI,并以基于访谈的方式评估这些构念的理论导向研究,有望增进我们对它们之间关系的理解。本综述最后对NSSI与生活压力之间的关联进行了理论阐述,旨在提供一个概念框架以指导该领域未来的研究。