Krishnan Reshma Poothakulath, Thangavelu Radhika, Rathnavelu Vidhya, Narasimhan Malathi
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Faculty of Dental Science, Sri Ramachandra University, Chennai 600116, India.
Department of Oral Pathology, Thai Moogambigai Dental College and Hospital, Mugappair, Chennai 600107, India.
Exp Ther Med. 2016 Jun;11(6):2329-2332. doi: 10.3892/etm.2016.3245. Epub 2016 Apr 11.
Personal identification has a pivotal role in forensic investigations. Gender determination is an essential step in personal identification. Despite the advent of advanced techniques such as DNA fingerprinting, methods such as lip print and fingerprint analysis and mandibular canine index calculations are routinely used in gender determination, as they are simple and cost-effective. The present study investigated the hypothesis that lip print analysis is an effective tool in gender determination compared with fingerprint analysis and the mandibular canine index. The predominant patterns of lip prints and fingerprints were analyzed in males and females, and the efficacy of the mandibular canine index in gender determination was evaluated. The study group comprised 50 students, 25 males and 25 females who were 18-25 years of age. Lip prints and fingerprints were obtained and classified according to Tsuchihashi's classification and Kücken and Newell's classification, respectively. Mandibular impressions were made and the mandibular canine index was calculated. Type I and Type I' lip prints were predominant in females, and Type IV lip prints were predominant in males. The analysis of fingerprints revealed that the loop fingerprint pattern was predominant in both males and females. The mandibular canine index was not found to be significant in gender identification. The predominant patterns of lip prints were distinct for males and females; conversely, fingerprints were demonstrated to be similar in both genders. Therefore, lip prints hold an increased potential for gender determination, as compared with fingerprints, and the mandibular canine index is not a reliable indicator of gender.
个人识别在法医调查中起着关键作用。性别鉴定是个人识别的重要步骤。尽管出现了诸如DNA指纹识别等先进技术,但唇纹和指纹分析以及下颌犬齿指数计算等方法仍经常用于性别鉴定,因为它们简单且具有成本效益。本研究调查了这样一个假设,即与指纹分析和下颌犬齿指数相比,唇纹分析是性别鉴定的有效工具。分析了男性和女性唇纹和指纹的主要模式,并评估了下颌犬齿指数在性别鉴定中的功效。研究组由50名18至25岁的学生组成,其中25名男性和25名女性。分别根据土桥分类法和屈肯与纽厄尔分类法获取并分类唇纹和指纹。制作下颌印模并计算下颌犬齿指数。I型和I'型唇纹在女性中占主导地位,IV型唇纹在男性中占主导地位。指纹分析显示,环状指纹模式在男性和女性中均占主导地位。未发现下颌犬齿指数在性别识别中有显著意义。男性和女性唇纹的主要模式明显不同;相反,指纹在两性中表现相似。因此,与指纹相比,唇纹在性别鉴定方面具有更大的潜力,而下颌犬齿指数不是性别可靠的指标。